Live data from Hacker News

Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

news.ycombinator.com

61–68 of 68 posts

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#61

Congrats on launching, and thank you for open sourcing! I've added your codebase to my list of open source React/Go applications to check out. 1. Do you worry that open sourcing will make it difficult for you to monetize? 2. Can you describe your tech stack more? 3. How long has your team been working on this?

1. We don't! We suspect that many companies running devices in production would rather pay for a hosted version of Deviceplane than have to maintain their own self-hosted install. We also offer support subscriptions of self-hosted installs. 2. If I had to summarize in one word, Golang. Our backend, agent, and CLI are all written in Go. Frontend is React + a custom component library we maintain. On the infrastructure…

Thanks!

I ran the `docker run ...` command you copy/pasted above and got the UI running quickly.

But, I couldn't install the agent on my Mac; perhaps macOS is not supported. This may be intentional, after all you're not building a desktop MDM tool, but I'd suggest providing a command to run an agent inside a Docker container (or something else).

This way people like me can start experimenting with DevicePlane without spinning up a Linux VM or EC2 instance.

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hiome looks cool, but that's quite the expensive occupancy sensor!

Thanks, our beta customers love them so far! Regarding price, each occupancy sensor is $79. These are high accuracy thermal sensors with local machine learning that can count occupancy. For comparison, a standard PIR motion sensor that can only tell you if there was motion in the last 30 seconds costs around $50 from Philips Hue or Eve. We think the price is very fair! :)

I guess I would never buy a PIR sensor for $50. You can get them for $6, so that's what I anchor off of. Not that I'd expect your product to be close to $6, but $50 PIR sensors are way overpriced, so I wouldn't ever think to compare to those.

Despite heavily automating my own home and being the person who sets everything up for my extended family, it seems I'm probably not your target market. Sounds like you have some cool tech though!

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Great question! We're in the same space as Balena and tackling some of the same problems, but with a different approach. Here are some of the big ways we defer from Balena (though these points really just scratch the surface). Balena ties you into their ecosystem a bit too much. They require you to use BalenaOS which means they only support a fixed number of devices. In contrast, Deviceplane can be used with any Linu…

I looked at Balena for my project but being tied so tightly to their eco-system and not being able to use it with regular Raspbian really put me off. However, one feature that looked useful was the ability to have one service per container and have them tied all together with docker compose. Do you support that architecture or does Deviceplace manage a single docker container which must contain all the services bundl…

We support multiple services, and we even support deploying multiple Docker Compose files per project!

Check out our deploying docs here: https://deviceplane.com/docs/deploying/

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#64
This is great timing for us too. At http://whoo.ai we make mobile video intercoms for apartment buildings. We install an Android device at the entrance to the building that lets visitors initiate a video call with the resident. We need a tool to manage those android devices (update and restart our app remotely... bonus if we can also restart the device). The devices are running as kiosks and need to be updated without any local interaction. We evaluated IBM’s Maas360 but it couldn’t do it without local interaction and IBM wanted a fortune to add the feature! I just signed up for a demo... looking forward to speaking with you. Arturo

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#65
Congratulation on the launch!

I would like to know if I can get yours and the communities comment on something.

I have interest in the ecosystem of open-source OTA and device management solutions and I try to keep up to date with things. When I saw your post on HN, I visited your github page (https://github.com/deviceplane/deviceplane) to learn more.

I was a bit surprised by the numbers on the github landing page which showed 800+ stars and 60+ forks. I typically look at these numbers to get a indication of project activity/popularity, obviously not the only metric to look at but normally a pretty good first data point.

This got me interested to learn more, as my initial though was that this project must have been around for a while with an active community. But things did not add up, the project only had 3 contributors (probably people from the company behind the project).

Looking closer at the forks (https://github.com/deviceplane/deviceplane/network/members), majority of them reference a different repository name (npm-algos) which does not seem to at all related to deviceplane. Then it became apparent to me that this must have been a rename of an organization and repository, as https://github.com/npm-algos/npm-algos redirects to https://github.com/deviceplane/deviceplane.

Now I became even more suspicions on what is going on here. So I did a bit more digging using the github API and looking up when the repository got their stars which showed that majority of the 800+ stars came before 2019-01 which was the "initial commit" of the deviceplane repository and the stars where dating back to 2015, so they must have been for the "npm-algos" repository.

Then to the conclusion, it seems that an older unrelated repository was repurposed (renamed) to manipulate metrics on github to provide a misleading view of activity/popularity. I find it hard to believe that something like this happened "accidentally", git repositories are fairly cheap :) and renaming an organization/repository on github is a somewhat involved process.

This is a practice I have never seen before, and not sure I like it. The goal seems to be to mislead users.

Would love to hear thoughts from the deviceplane folks, but also from the HN community.

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#66
post #65

Congratulation on the launch! I would like to know if I can get yours and the communities comment on something. I have interest in the ecosystem of open-source OTA and device management solutions and I try to keep up to date with things. When I saw your post on HN, I visited your github page ( https://github.com/deviceplane/deviceplane ) to learn more. I was a bit surprised by the numbers on the github landing page w…

[deleted]

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#67
post #65

Congratulation on the launch! I would like to know if I can get yours and the communities comment on something. I have interest in the ecosystem of open-source OTA and device management solutions and I try to keep up to date with things. When I saw your post on HN, I visited your github page ( https://github.com/deviceplane/deviceplane ) to learn more. I was a bit surprised by the numbers on the github landing page w…

[deleted]

Re: Launch HN: Deviceplane (YC W20) – Update and Manage Devices Running Linux

#68
post #65

Congratulation on the launch! I would like to know if I can get yours and the communities comment on something. I have interest in the ecosystem of open-source OTA and device management solutions and I try to keep up to date with things. When I saw your post on HN, I visited your github page ( https://github.com/deviceplane/deviceplane ) to learn more. I was a bit surprised by the numbers on the github landing page w…

Strange. Deviceplane now only has 56 stars.
Post reply on HN