The invite-only nature will only benefit the site while it's small. It will either stay small or suffer the same users as other sites. The down-vote with reason feature is nice.
Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
11–20 of 179 posts
Re: Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
#12Ah, the what.cd strategy. Minus the exclusive content.
Re: Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
#13The invite-only nature will only benefit the site while it's small. It will either stay small or suffer the same users as other sites. The down-vote with reason feature is nice.
I'll be interested to see how they leverage the user tree. I'm no expert in social media bots, but it seems like the user invitation tree could be important to identifying not just networks of bots that are generating low-value content and trying to amplify certain viewpoints, but the people inviting those bots into the network in the first place.
This is a throwback to an early age when you would never talk to someone in social circles without first being introduced. If someone turned out to be a "bad sort" then the mutual acquaintance who had introduced you had proven themselves not to be reliable, and so you don't trust any future introduction from them. The scene in "Pride and Prejudice" where Mr Collins goes up to talk to Mr Darcy without having been introduced is a classic example of breaking these social norms, and the loss of reputation that ensues.
There is a lot of current research on "reputation" and "trust", and the "invitation tree" is one very simple way to provide some of the benefits.
Re: Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
#14Re: Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
#15Also I notice a lot of Lobste.rs is a mix between my fav subreddits & HN. So it's a circlejerk. But then again r/programmingcirclejerk is one of my favorite subreddits anyway.
Re: Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
#16Earlier quoted context omitted.
I'll be interested to see how they leverage the user tree. I'm no expert in social media bots, but it seems like the user invitation tree could be important to identifying not just networks of bots that are generating low-value content and trying to amplify certain viewpoints, but the people inviting those bots into the network in the first place.
It was already used when dealing with voting rings (resulting in termination of accounts)
Re: Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
#17The invite-only nature will only benefit the site while it's small. It will either stay small or suffer the same users as other sites. The down-vote with reason feature is nice.
If someone on the top of a user-invite tree gets "cancelled" will all the people he referred and their descendants be cancelled, too?
Re: Why Lobste.rs Is Better Than Hacker News
#18"It’s invite only." So it's a clique. I thought we grew past these after high school.