Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

news.ycombinator.com

161–170 of 272 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#161
While reading the comments I thought, "Surely there's a way to auto-submit bookmarks to the Wayback Machine, yes?" A moment of searching unearthed a Firefox extension for doing that. The commit logs at the Github repo show continual development since 2015.

Installer: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/archiveror/

Repo: https://github.com/rahiel/archiveror

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#162

If you're willing to tag things so you can find them later, then https://pinboard.in If you're not then don't store them, just google them when you need them. That will either help you find the link you wanted, or it will find you something better, because the world has moved on since then.

You don't necessarily have to tag them, if you pay a bit extra for full-text archive, then import your browser's bookmarks.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#163
I run a bookmark manager on my home web server (accessible from the internet). I prefer that over managing bookmarks using browser facilities, because I can use bookmarks from any browser and any machine, anywhere. I also don't have to worry about losing bookmarks if I change browsers, replace the OS, etc.

I'm also a bit allergic to using some external service to do this -- that seems like a pointless loss of control to me.

(I use Online Bookmarks http://www.frech.ch/online-bookmarks/ for this)

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#164

If you're willing to tag things so you can find them later, then https://pinboard.in If you're not then don't store them, just google them when you need them. That will either help you find the link you wanted, or it will find you something better, because the world has moved on since then.

Wholeheartedly agree with this. I've been very happy with pinboard, the one area that could use improvement is on the mobile side: it's a bit annoying to set a new bookmark in a mobile browser.

Pinner works fine on iOS.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#165

At what point do bookmarks essentially become an internet of your own making? I guess you need to create a search engine so you can search your bookmark collection, or maybe a Yahoo style directory to browse them. Or... Stop collecting the internet and give your brain a break from data overload. There is a certain flavour of FOMO that keeps tabs open forever and bookmark lists getting huge. Let go of it all. There wi…

> Use Google when you want to go back to something.

Yeah, good luck with that. Most of the things I bookmark are things that were really hard to find in the first place. Google isn't much help with stuff like that.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#166
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except with google it’s becoming impossible to find links from several years ago. Unless I remember exactly the right keywords and maybe the website name... How is this FOMO? The entire point of bookmarks is “maybe I’ll come back later to this”. Bookmarks let you save content that you come across that may not be relevant at this time, but could be useful later. There is no penalty for saving pages because space is vi…

Google (and related services, such as youtube) allows you to use before:YYYY-MM-DD and after:YYYY-MM-DD to only show results that were created before or after a certain date.

You're suggesting spending a lot of time and hassle trying to wrestle with search engines instead of just keeping a bookmark that can be found and accessed very quickly?

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But after search got good, it got bad. Or at least increasingly strained by the sheer magnitude of shit now online.

It's still better than the early 2000's, which is the last time I really needed "bookmarks."

My experience with this is very, very different. I think Google search has generally become much worse than then, although other search engines seem to be at about early 2000's quality level.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#168

A while back someone on here posted a reply to a similar question for me - and it was one of those 'road to Damascus' moments for me. The poster pointed out that we should not have to bookmark - that why do our own browsers not simply record every site we visits (and even cache the text for alter searching). Its technically trivial. But we all have this blind spot - that it is perfectly reasonable for massive corpora…

> we all have this blind spot - that it is perfectly reasonable for massive corporations to collect where we visit

I don't think this is reasonable at all.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#169

At what point do bookmarks essentially become an internet of your own making? I guess you need to create a search engine so you can search your bookmark collection, or maybe a Yahoo style directory to browse them. Or... Stop collecting the internet and give your brain a break from data overload. There is a certain flavour of FOMO that keeps tabs open forever and bookmark lists getting huge. Let go of it all. There wi…

I feel like you might be missing out on the fact that people use bookmarks in different ways. I don't download most apps on my phone, so I use everything through firefox web browser on my android phone and I dont like having a million tabs open on my phone. So I use bookmarks to quickly get me to my bank or youtube or paypal, etc etc etc. Bookmarks arent just a tool for people to stash random things they'll never come back to. Sometimes people actually use bookmarks regularly for just day to day browsing.

Re: Ask HN: How do you manage your bookmarks?

#170
post #162

If you're willing to tag things so you can find them later, then https://pinboard.in If you're not then don't store them, just google them when you need them. That will either help you find the link you wanted, or it will find you something better, because the world has moved on since then.

You don't necessarily have to tag them, if you pay a bit extra for full-text archive, then import your browser's bookmarks.

Are there any services where you can submit a URL and get a list of tags back curated by humans?

EDIT: Looks like Pinboard does this already! Mea culpa.

Post reply on HN