Live data from Hacker News

Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

imgur.com

31–40 of 124 posts

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#31
The EU is a nightmare of over regulation. No wonder the U.K. is leaving. They can’t just leave people well enough alone.

Imgur has recently started displaying a GDPR cookie notice modal over the entire page on their image only URLs. I feel like I can’t escape the EU’s ruination of the Internet and I have never stepped foot in the bloc.

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#32
there's a bizarre trend in Germany in the last few months for legistlating completely unneccesary things. This is a great example.

Additionally today they announced that while profits on stock trading (specifically derivatives) can be taxed fully, losses can only be accounted for upto 10.000€

Berlin is trying to freeze rents for the next 5 years and make it possible to retroactively lower rents to the level of 2013.

This kids, is what it looks like when a government is too scared to solve bigger structural challenges (digitization of the beauraucracy, switch to electromobility, better competitive environment for startups, questionable pension system, unneccesarily high taxes that keep leading to surpluses, I could go on) - and instead keep themselves occupied with non-issues that are PR heavy. Schade.

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#33
post #25

Who's pushing for this? Meme's are free advertising for the rights holder. It's like media industries love to hurt themselves. They've already brought back mass piracy by fragmenting streaming services, next they want to kill any chance of their content going viral I guess.

This is just a consequence of the copyright reform by the EU that passed. Remember article 11 and 13? (15 and 17 when passed.) This is it. The EU can't make laws themselves: it gets the national governments to make the laws and this is the one for Germany.

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#34

there's a bizarre trend in Germany in the last few months for legistlating completely unneccesary things. This is a great example. Additionally today they announced that while profits on stock trading (specifically derivatives) can be taxed fully, losses can only be accounted for upto 10.000€ Berlin is trying to freeze rents for the next 5 years and make it possible to retroactively lower rents to the level of 2013.…

I'm pretty sure this is just a consequence of that EU copyright reform that passed some months ago (article 11&13/15&17). At least the linked article talks about it (in German).

The EU can't make laws themselves. The way they work is by requiring member states to make laws and this is Germany's.

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#35
post #4

actual article (in german) https://www.golem.de/news/leistungsschutzrecht-memes-sollen-...

Leistungsshultzrecht is the "Link tax" so this shouldn't apply to "memes" but to snippets of news

(Of course, the link tax is BS, but it's not exactly related to memes)

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#37

I wonder if this stupid compliance trick works: encode the image in base64 (or whatever, maybe something more dense), output that as plain text in the page, tell users they need to install a browser extension that recognizes these parts, decodes them and puts the image in place of the text. Just for kicks the browser extension is open source and is maintained by anonymous..

It sounds like you're falling into a common pitfall of interpreting laws in terms of purely technical details rather than their intent.

I recommend reading What Colour are your bits [0].

The major point that it tries to get across is that as software devs, we think in terms of data and computers. The law doesn't. The law says "you can't have an image like X", and you immediately think "hah, well, arbitrary base64 encoded data isn't an image." The law doesn't care about that though. If the law says you can't display an image like X to users, then it doesn't matter what weird layers you go through. It doesn't matter if you stitch together 1 million 1-pixel images, or if you have them install a browser extension, it just matters if you intended for them to be able to see that image, and then they could see that image.

The blog-post I linked does a much better job of explaining this, and I recommend reading it.

[0]: https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#38

This is only for commercial usage, private and non commercial is explicitly exempted.

Commercial... memes?

Well, commercial use of memes, like, say a company liek Reddit or Imgur that profites from the use of memes (let's not go into their revenue or business model in detail now). So in reality ALL memes are commercial (unless you host yourself, I would guess).

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#39

The EU is a nightmare of over regulation. No wonder the U.K. is leaving. They can’t just leave people well enough alone. Imgur has recently started displaying a GDPR cookie notice modal over the entire page on their image only URLs. I feel like I can’t escape the EU’s ruination of the Internet and I have never stepped foot in the bloc.

The hope behind GDPR, as with the earlier "cookie law" was that businesses would respond by improving their revenue models and data practices. Instead businesses have responded by making the UX shit for their users whilst claiming they had to do it to follow the law.

Re: Draft of German copyright reform proposes memes should only be up to 128 pixels

#40

The EU is a nightmare of over regulation. No wonder the U.K. is leaving. They can’t just leave people well enough alone. Imgur has recently started displaying a GDPR cookie notice modal over the entire page on their image only URLs. I feel like I can’t escape the EU’s ruination of the Internet and I have never stepped foot in the bloc.

> Imgur has recently started displaying a GDPR cookie notice modal

I find it hilarious how companies allegedly afraid of the big bad fines by the EU continue to use a non-compliant solution for a problem they created themselves.

It's cargo-culting of the stupidest way of (barely) solving the problem. American lawyers trying to interpret EU regulations never worked well it seems.

> I have never stepped foot in the bloc

It's not like the rest of the world doesn't have to obey several American laws as well.

Post reply on HN