Live data from Hacker News

Weleakinfo.com Domain Name Seized: Site Had Sold Access to Hacked PII and Logins

justice.gov

1–10 of 14 posts

Re: Weleakinfo.com Domain Name Seized: Site Had Sold Access to Hacked PII and Logins

#3
I wonder if this is ever a positive thing. Like if a company sold 0.01% of the leaked credentials to prove the hack was real/scare the general public. And then shredded the other 99.99% of credentials.

I feel like the nuance would almost always be lost though

Re: Weleakinfo.com Domain Name Seized: Site Had Sold Access to Hacked PII and Logins

#4

I wonder if this is ever a positive thing. Like if a company sold 0.01% of the leaked credentials to prove the hack was real/scare the general public. And then shredded the other 99.99% of credentials. I feel like the nuance would almost always be lost though

Considering the Equifax breach, which consisted of leaking all the information on everyone, and didn't seem to phase the public hardly at all, I don't think that would be an effective tactic.

Re: Weleakinfo.com Domain Name Seized: Site Had Sold Access to Hacked PII and Logins

#6
At what point do security dumps become 'public' and legal to disseminate?

Is there a framework for determining what is legal to provide to Brian Krebs or Haveibeenpwned.com?

Would it have been illegal of Brian Krebs to pay money to weleakinfo.com for a database that also existed elsewhere?

Basically is it illegal to buy, sell, give away for free to masses, give away for free to vetted individuals/researchers, or illegal to hold privately once you received it?

Would love if anyone could point me towards the path of enlightenment here. US/EU, and other laws all seem relevant.

Re: Weleakinfo.com Domain Name Seized: Site Had Sold Access to Hacked PII and Logins

#10
post #6

At what point do security dumps become 'public' and legal to disseminate? Is there a framework for determining what is legal to provide to Brian Krebs or Haveibeenpwned.com? Would it have been illegal of Brian Krebs to pay money to weleakinfo.com for a database that also existed elsewhere? Basically is it illegal to buy, sell, give away for free to masses, give away for free to vetted individuals/researchers, or ille…

I asked a lawyer friend this question once before starting on a personal project. The answer I got in return took about 30 minutes and was filled with a lot of "ifs" and "buts" and references to at-that-time undecided cases.
Post reply on HN