Live data from Hacker News

Actix project postmortem

github.com

11–20 of 408 posts

Re: Actix project postmortem

#11
"Ok... So that was unprofessional. If you don't want to maintain a project anymore, you give it to someone else and link to that repo in your README.

This just screwed me over big time."

https://github.com/actix/actix-web/issues/1#issuecomment-575...

These kind of entitled attitude is probably exactly why the guy just removed everything.

More details / discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/epszt7/actixnet_unsou...

Re: Actix project postmortem

#12

"Ok... So that was unprofessional. If you don't want to maintain a project anymore, you give it to someone else and link to that repo in your README. This just screwed me over big time." https://github.com/actix/actix-web/issues/1#issuecomment-575... These kind of entitled attitude is probably exactly why the guy just removed everything. More details / discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/epszt7/ac…

They're right, it was unprofessional... but since the maintainer is not being paid this is not a professional project. It's a personal project. And this seems like a perfectly personal thing to do with something that's preventing happiness.

Re: Actix project postmortem

#13
Open source maintainers have a hard time - especially when they're under criticism and receive zero positive vibes. Author mentions it, here's the excerpt:

Be a maintainer of large open source project is not a fun task. You alway face with rude and hate, everyone knows better how to build software, nobody wants to do home work and read docs and think a bit and very few provide any help.

This a big problem with open source - I, as a programmer, like when someone commends me. It might be childish, but if I invest a few days into code and someone finds it useful - I would love to hear it, it would make the day for me. Instead, I had similar experience like the author of actix - hatred, rudeness and a lot of people who don't read the docs, they merely expect everything to work if they drop the library into their project.

Sadly, we're way too negative and don't appreciate OSS maintainers. This trend should change. It's sad to see yet another project go because author was mentally drained due to negativity. We should take care of our own "brothers in arms" (we all write code or deal with tech, don't we?).

I haven't used Actix-web, but I can sympathize with the author. Keep your head up, recharge your batteries and remain creative. Good luck with your future products!

Re: Actix project postmortem

#14
post #4

Asking for a friend - could someone explain what happened there? The README doc is quite vague - it is more of a personal justification than a rationale (to me).

Sounds like the maintainer writes a lot of code using rust's "unsafe" keyword, and regularly gets issues raised about this (and versioning, and some other bits). This last issue, which included a patch, has pushed them over the edge after it descended into disagreement. Net/net they were repeatedly asked to change coding style, didn't want to, and have decided it's better to just avoid the arguments by not publishing…

The maintainer can choose whatever style they damn well please, if you don't like it don't use it.

What is hard about this?

Re: Actix project postmortem

#15

"Ok... So that was unprofessional. If you don't want to maintain a project anymore, you give it to someone else and link to that repo in your README. This just screwed me over big time." https://github.com/actix/actix-web/issues/1#issuecomment-575... These kind of entitled attitude is probably exactly why the guy just removed everything. More details / discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/epszt7/ac…

Now due to that comment actix maintainer has disabled issue too. I don't know why people show such attitude as if they are paying him to do opensource.

Re: Actix project postmortem

#16

"Ok... So that was unprofessional. If you don't want to maintain a project anymore, you give it to someone else and link to that repo in your README. This just screwed me over big time." https://github.com/actix/actix-web/issues/1#issuecomment-575... These kind of entitled attitude is probably exactly why the guy just removed everything. More details / discussion here: https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/epszt7/ac…

They're right, it was unprofessional... but since the maintainer is not being paid this is not a professional project. It's a personal project. And this seems like a perfectly personal thing to do with something that's preventing happiness.

Well, it's easy to get confused when you look at the professional looking website with a well crafted logo, a promo list of features and a copyright notice from the "The Actix Team". The community page even says "We're a welcoming community so don't be afraid to engage.". Ouch!

Re: Actix project postmortem

#17
People should really learn to ignore the emotional channel of the comments they receive. Just try to figure out if the message contains any useful information with a quick glance, extract it if it does and ignore the rest. People have to shit - that's physiologically inevitable, and there are people who do it in the streets and there are people who shit in comments/messages. Why take them serious?

Re: Actix project postmortem

#18
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like the maintainer writes a lot of code using rust's "unsafe" keyword, and regularly gets issues raised about this (and versioning, and some other bits). This last issue, which included a patch, has pushed them over the edge after it descended into disagreement. Net/net they were repeatedly asked to change coding style, didn't want to, and have decided it's better to just avoid the arguments by not publishing…

The maintainer can choose whatever style they damn well please, if you don't like it don't use it. What is hard about this?

Is it a community run project or not? The website seems to imply that the community is welcome to participate: "We're a welcoming community so don't be afraid to engage."
Post reply on HN