Live data from Hacker News

Firefox Multi-Account Containers

addons.mozilla.org

151–160 of 160 posts

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#151
post #51

I have been using this for a while now, it's pretty good, but I always had trouble separating Gmail and Google search. It's necessary to add accounts.google.com and mail.google.com I think I can't isolate Google search to ours own container. I'm also using strict setting and cookies are cleared when Firefox is closed, and Gmail and accounts domain are white listed. The UI of this addon could be a little better.

Do you want to be logged in while using Google search? I don't. So I have 2 Google containers (work + private) where I am logged in for Gmail, Drive etc. But search, maps, etc. I do in a 3rd container. Yeah, you cannot blindly follow all links, but that doesn't bother me too much.

I don't want to be logged in when searching.

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#152
post #124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is the user interface like for Firefox profiles?

You can judge for yourself by typing 'firefox -P -no-remote'. Right there, having to use the terminal , has already made it more clunkier than Chromium's solution. Admittedly, Firefox profiles are clunkier to launch & manage - like a hidden feature that has rebuffed all my attempts to streamline their management, as if by design. This can be remedied by use of desktop shortcuts (You can create separate shortcuts for…

Command line - I rest my case.

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#153

Pair it with "containerise" ( https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/containerise/ ). With containerise, you can easily edit a text file (host, container name) to create/edit/backup multiple containers.

Does it sync this across multiple machines? Can I export/import this list?

Unfortunately, it doesn't sync. You can copy the text anywhere (e.g. email to yourself!) and use it elsewhere; it's still a much better UX compared to the built-in functionality.

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For annoying cookies popups you can try this https://addons.mozilla.org/it/firefox/addon/i-dont-care-abou...

Or just use ublocks existing filters that catch these...

Or both: Use 'I don't care about cookies' list in uBlock: https://www.i-dont-care-about-cookies.eu/abp/

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#155
post #124

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can judge for yourself by typing 'firefox -P -no-remote'. Right there, having to use the terminal , has already made it more clunkier than Chromium's solution. Admittedly, Firefox profiles are clunkier to launch & manage - like a hidden feature that has rebuffed all my attempts to streamline their management, as if by design. This can be remedied by use of desktop shortcuts (You can create separate shortcuts for…

Command line - I rest my case.

Either way my point stands. Firefox containers aren't profiles and imo shouldn't replace them. They should make profiles more user-accessible, but both solutions should exist simultaneously. If anything, effective use of containers requires more advanced knowledge & awareness making it more suitaed for advanced users.

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#156
post #143
post #130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How do you open new, specific, container tabs with a keystroke then ? As far as I can tell, the only way to open a specific container tab is to mousey-mouse-mouse to: File > New Container Tab > Blah Of course that use-case should be preserved, but it's woefully inefficient ... if you have a profile you do a lot of things under, you'd create a window and then (keystroke) (CMD)-t to get a new tab ...

It's not super-efficient, but it is keyboard accessible: press Ctrl+. to open the Container selection menu, then the down arrow to the Container you want, and Enter to open a new tab in that Container.

Actually, I see that you can press number keys to spawn the container tab you want in that pick-list.

So, you don't need to down-arrow and pick, you can just:

ctrl + . (ctrl + period)

then hit '1' or '2' ...

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#157
post #113
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same! I have three (dev, stg, prd) aws accounts. Without containers, I'd need to log in and out to jump between s3/emr/etc buckets between environments. With firefox containers I can run all three concurrently.

One can do that with ff profile, right? Is the only different between this containers vs profile the container is tab base vs profile will be different windows?

I've opted for profiles. With profiles, it's like getting a completely new browser. You start off with the default about:config, preferences and no extensions.

The way my main FF browser is set up, I have multiple privacy enhancing extensions (including uMatrix), highly modified config, tightening of privacy preferences, WebRTC off, service workers disabled, telemetry disabled, etc and etc... This can create some problems on sites that pour hundreds of millions into tracking, data-collection.

So I have additional profiles that are Amazon-specific, Google-specific. If I facebook'd, I'd have a profile for them too. Each of these domain-based profiles are far more liberal (minimal extensions and such; fewer config tweaks). I even have a profile that's 100% Private Mode (ie, history, cookies... deleted after shutdown) with it's own set of config tweaks and extensions.

I use my privacy-enhanced default FF for most sites w/o issues. I wanted Google and Amazon completely separate while providing them more access to my browser (so that I could enjoy the full web experience without worry that a browser issue would make it easy for them to steal my entire browser usage). So they're free to rummage around, read cookies, access APIs - but they're only getting their own stuff back.

I feel profiles provide a better defense (all settings, cookies, storage in their own subDirectory) and much more flexibility than containers.

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#158
post #156
post #143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not super-efficient, but it is keyboard accessible: press Ctrl+. to open the Container selection menu, then the down arrow to the Container you want, and Enter to open a new tab in that Container.

Actually, I see that you can press number keys to spawn the container tab you want in that pick-list. So, you don't need to down-arrow and pick, you can just: ctrl + . (ctrl + period) then hit '1' or '2' ...

Well, today I learned - thanks!

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#159
post #130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> This would seem to be the basic, beginning use-case from which all other use-cases would follow. I would never ever want to do that. So, no, it is not the basic, beginning use-case. It is a worthless use case for me. You shouldn't assume that your use cases are the obvious ones.

How do you open new, specific, container tabs with a keystroke then ? As far as I can tell, the only way to open a specific container tab is to mousey-mouse-mouse to: File > New Container Tab > Blah Of course that use-case should be preserved, but it's woefully inefficient ... if you have a profile you do a lot of things under, you'd create a window and then (keystroke) (CMD)-t to get a new tab ...

Why would I want to do that?

I type in a URL and Firefox knows which container to open it in already.

I've been using Firefox with containers since it came out and I've never wanted to do that.

Re: Firefox Multi-Account Containers

#160

Nice. Now my wife and I can both stay logged in to our email. I've wanted this feature for 15 years. Now, bring multi row tabs back and FF will be awesome again.

Another option is setting Firefox to open the profile manager[0].

That's what I've always done when I don't want to use multiple accounts on the machine itself.

[0]https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/profile-manager-create-...

Post reply on HN