Live data from Hacker News

The Oregon DMV took in $11.5M last year by selling your information

katu.com

21–23 of 23 posts

Re: The Oregon DMV took in $11.5M last year by selling your information

#21
post #17
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is raising taxes preferable though? In the present scenario, taxes are lower, because the government is making up for it by selling my info to marketeers, who then try to sell me crap I don't want. I don't buy any of it, but a percentage of my more-gullible neighbors do. So, in effect, the more gullible citizens are subsidizing the smarter or at least more frugal ones. Alternatively, if the government stopped selling…

Like I said, of course it's more complicated than that. Also, I will point out, that we are all "stupid" at some point. For instance young people and elderly people are more susceptible to scams/advertisement. If you think you will never be elderly, that's fine, but maybe I want my parents to be protected.

Personally, I don't think elderly people who've become gullible have any business operating a motor vehicle. It's a massive failure of our society that not being stuck at home in most places requires a car, and this should be fixed. This would also mostly eliminate the need for a DMV.

Re: The Oregon DMV took in $11.5M last year by selling your information

#22
post #18
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm guessing maybe both. I don't see why my dealer would want someone else trying to sell me a warranty extension; that competes directly with the dealer.

The dealer likely hit you with a warranty extension pitch during the sales process. So the only potential sales cannibalization would be from individuals that _might_ have purchased a warranty from the dealer after the sale. The guaranteed revenue from leasing out the list would more than likely makes up for that possibility, especially if it's coordinated at the manufacturer level.

Dealers will also hit you with warranty extension pitches shortly before your warranty expires. But you're right, they might be figuring that selling that info to competitors might net them more money than relying on their own sales tactics.
Post reply on HN