Live data from Hacker News

Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

kevinrooke.com

71–80 of 696 posts

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#71
Do Airpods have a built-in microphone, and audio/ambient mixing (with ratio controllable through the phone)?

I can't believe this feature is not standard on today's headphone products, especially digital ones.

edit: Thanks for the responses. Looks like Airpods pro do have this feature. Thumbs up!

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#72
post #7

What intrigues me more than the features of the AirPods -- especially the new AirPods Pro -- is that these little things have the potential to be a platform to themselves: https://www.aboveavalon.com/notes/2019/11/19/airpods-are-bec...

> This dynamic could be extended so that a simple tap of an AirPod or a quick voice command can take us to a different location via sound. Utilizing HomePods as sound receivers, an AirPods wearer would be able to “move” from the kitchen to family room. That idea of transporting yourself to another location through the use of sound is absolutely fascinating. I think developers should and will start to consider how sou…

That idea of transporting yourself to another location through the use of sound is absolutely fascinating. I think developers should and will start to consider how sound enhances existing experiences, and how new experiences can come from looking at audio output and input as tools to be used to reach the user.

I seem to remember that Microsoft released an app for the iPhone that is a map service, but it works on sound only because it's designed for blind people.

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#73
post #40

Amazing how Apple managed to make the first cool MP3 player, then the first cool smartphone and now the first cool bluetooth headset. For almost 20 years now, Apple has owned electronic fashion. Sony for example was unable to parlay its Walkman dominance into similar positions with new devices. And make no mistake about it - a huge portion of these sales are people buying Apple's marketing - not buying the tech itsel…

Not sure about the marketing swaying people these days. People are going for the easiest devices to use that get out of the way and are high quality.

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#74
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>With the kicker that it is only stored locally Do you think most people would want to lose all their data if they lose their device?

It's certainly possible for the Apple Health data to be backed up to iCloud. I haven't changed devices recently, so I don't know if it is.

Correct... it's backed up to iCloud or on your computer with itunes if you encrypt it.

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#75
post #24

I have a pair of Airpods. What bugs me most is that le lithium battery is not replaceable, and will degrade after a couple years. which makes these a high-end throwaway device...

That doesn't differ from their other offerings... Their laptops and phones do not have replaceable batteries, why would their headphones?

Except their laptops and phones totally do...

What are you talking about?

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#76
A couple years ago, I got a bit of saltwater in my iPhone and the headphone jack failed. Since the next generation of iPhone (the iPhone X) was about to come out, I held onto it for a couple months and bought AirPods.

I then realized this was Apple's real reason for eliminating the headphone jack. It had nothing to do with courage. It was about eliminating a deeply ingrained user habit so they could solve the problem they themselves created. I wouldn't have bothered with the AirPods if my headphone jack had continued to function.

That said, I don't know if Apple's strategy bothers me. There are a lot of user behaviors rooted in history and old constraints rather than good usability. There are a lot of downsides, but as someone who views technology as ephemeral I don't know if it matters to me.

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#77
post #66
post #40

Amazing how Apple managed to make the first cool MP3 player, then the first cool smartphone and now the first cool bluetooth headset. For almost 20 years now, Apple has owned electronic fashion. Sony for example was unable to parlay its Walkman dominance into similar positions with new devices. And make no mistake about it - a huge portion of these sales are people buying Apple's marketing - not buying the tech itsel…

>now the first cool bluetooth headset [citation needed] Honstly every time I see someone wearing earpods I can't take him seriously anymore, they look _so_ bad. There's a lot of options on the market, and airpods are the ugliest of them all.

When you talk to people, you're supposed to look at their eyes, not their ears.

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#78

I have a pair of Airpods. What bugs me most is that le lithium battery is not replaceable, and will degrade after a couple years. which makes these a high-end throwaway device...

And what apple is betting on is that people will prefer their totally sealed, light as possible, "throwaway" $200 product over the competitions user service, replaceable battery option.

It is the same bet they have made repeatedly with their phones. Smaller sim card (obsoleting old approaches) - removing headphone jack, switching to lighting, doing totally sealed (but durable) devices etc.

It's generally paid off - oddly people seem to prefer used apple products (ie, beleive in their durability) over used logitech headphones or android phones - so the actual life of apple products ends up being pretty long.

Apple's battery service fee is $49 for airpods and useful life is perhaps around 3 years, if you keep wanting to replace the batteries every three years. My quick sense is that most folks may retire their airpods after the second battery (6 years in) at the longer end.

So far their approach has paid of tremendously for them.

I am curious what other headphone providers are doing here. Ie, how easy is it to get a fresh set of batteries after 3 years that are of high quality and replace them. I've gotten burned replacing batteries in products with amazon replacements and the mfg sometimes doesn't even stock or sell new batteries for their devices so I've gone with Apple for now - if you go into their store for a new battery I've never had a problem with quality.

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#79
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Always in ear Airpods stopped reading there.

> stopped reading there. says much more about your limitations than about airpods... ever heard of hearing aids?

Yes, and people hate them, but there are no alternatives. Why would you want something permanently in your ear to measure heart rate?

Re: Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?

#80
post #40

Amazing how Apple managed to make the first cool MP3 player, then the first cool smartphone and now the first cool bluetooth headset. For almost 20 years now, Apple has owned electronic fashion. Sony for example was unable to parlay its Walkman dominance into similar positions with new devices. And make no mistake about it - a huge portion of these sales are people buying Apple's marketing - not buying the tech itsel…

Beats invented the first cool bluetooth headset.
Post reply on HN