Live data from Hacker News

The Light Phone

thelightphone.com

11–20 of 291 posts

Re: The Light Phone

#11
I think an Apple Watch with cellular accomplishes a lot of what light phone does. Leave your phone behind and just keep all the social apps off the watch (they’re not really usable anyway).

You can still accomplish a lot of what you need from a phone, and pair some AirPods and you have music, podcasts, easy hands free calling

Re: The Light Phone

#12
I get this is supposed to be minimalist but the texting interaction looks really rough. You read threaded conversations in portrait mode but to reply it switches you to landscape mode where you can’t see the conversation and can only see the reply you’re typing. Nokia candy bar phones from the mid 90s let me type a reply while looking at what I was replying to.

This seems like an oversight

Re: The Light Phone

#13
post #7

I wonder where this is heading. The original light phone (version 1 if I remember correctly) was simply for calling and very minimalistic. To that I am a bit disappointed that they are adding more features instead of cutting prices.

There were some background articles explaining they had to. The first version was too minimalist, not even the phone makers ended up using them. The set of the absolutely necessary services for a phone is bigger than one would think and it differs more - does it include maps? taxi services? texting? Answer will vary a lot, and by making it too minimalist they would end up satisfying no one.

It's interesting to see exactly that happening in the comments here - "if it only had X, Y and Z I would buy it".

Re: The Light Phone

#16

I get this is supposed to be minimalist but the texting interaction looks really rough. You read threaded conversations in portrait mode but to reply it switches you to landscape mode where you can’t see the conversation and can only see the reply you’re typing. Nokia candy bar phones from the mid 90s let me type a reply while looking at what I was replying to. This seems like an oversight

Maybe that’s intentional, so you focus on short messages rather than sprawling conversations.

Re: The Light Phone

#17

I get this is supposed to be minimalist but the texting interaction looks really rough. You read threaded conversations in portrait mode but to reply it switches you to landscape mode where you can’t see the conversation and can only see the reply you’re typing. Nokia candy bar phones from the mid 90s let me type a reply while looking at what I was replying to. This seems like an oversight

Maybe that’s intentional, so you focus on short messages rather than sprawling conversations.

Why force that choice on me?

Re: The Light Phone

#18

I get this is supposed to be minimalist but the texting interaction looks really rough. You read threaded conversations in portrait mode but to reply it switches you to landscape mode where you can’t see the conversation and can only see the reply you’re typing. Nokia candy bar phones from the mid 90s let me type a reply while looking at what I was replying to. This seems like an oversight

I'd say the Nokia still wins out over this, that's without even looking at the price. How many Nokia's could you get for $350.

Then there is this aspect: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=thelightphone.com

Which does kinda make you wonder many things, more so, that price. Everything else seems to of been already covered in past discussions over the many many years.

Re: The Light Phone

#19
post #15
post #14

E-ink screen, but the battery life is bad. I can go about a week with mine.

The 950mAh battery is extremely small.

It's still very low even given the battery size. The updated Nokia 3310 has a traditional display with a 1200 mAh battery and is rated for a standby battery life of 31 days.

At 950 mAh that would be just over 24 days. I would expect an improvement in battery life with E-ink.

https://www.nokia.com/phones/en_int/nokia-3310#details

Re: The Light Phone

#20
post #8

I'm curious to see what would happen if someone made a simple phone that behaved as an access point. Hook up my watch, my tablet, bluetooth headphones, let it stay in my pocket most of the time.

That sounds exactly like a portable Wi-Fi hotspot which creates a hotspot from a 4G sim.
Post reply on HN