Live data from Hacker News

Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

itvision.altervista.org

191–200 of 326 posts

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#191

it's funny to read a rant from a ex-Microsoft and sad that he doesn't know why Microsoft still have a vast market share. I've been in the IT game for 10+ years. small/mid companies doesn't have the budget or man powers to leave the MS's lala land and they can care less. IT is a money losing dept and they need to make money by focus on what they do best. Windows is a platform where most of their software work and thei…

IT costs money yes, but it's not like there is ZERO ROI. Just because the value isn't immediately obvious doesn't mean it's not helping the business and it's bottom line. I agree that certain aspects of IT you should try to minimize cost because the value add is minimal, or because throwing more money at that aspect of IT does not help the business. But other aspects of IT that improve efficiency of the organization…

[deleted]

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#192
post #69

It's worth a mention just how buggy win10 has been for me. I don't spend much time working in windows, but every time I do I encounter one issue or another. File explorer freezes / crashes. There is that one empty folder on my desktop that I cannot delete because it is in use, but there is nothing in the folder and no program is conceivably using it. There are occasional glitches with git. It wouldn't let me clone a…

> File explorer freezes / crashes. It's been happening to me too, but it's unclear to me if it's one of my shell extensions or Windows itself. Do you run any shell extensions? > There are occasional glitches with git. It wouldn't let me clone a git repo somewhere because it said the folder already existed. No such folder existed. Changing the destination name did nothing. Restarting fixed it. That's mind-boggling. We…

> It's been happening to me too, but it's unclear to me if it's one of my shell extensions or Windows itself. Do you run any shell extensions?

only shellex here is 7zfm integration and I get occasional explorer.exe crashes. Also I had an install where edge just wouldn't start. At all.

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#193

I've started a list since getting my Win 10 machine at work: 1. Sometimes when I select the titlebar of a maximized window to move it to my second monitor it somehow selects the window under the one with focus. 2. For some applications (including MS Office ones) text is blurry when I move from laptop screen to external monitor. 4. Windows 10 ships with a python.exe in the path that opens the MS Store. Figuring out wh…

How on earth are you avoiding things like #2 on Debian? The only OS I've found that properly handles arbitrary DPI since day 1 has been Android. Also you skipped #3 in your list

echo "Xft.dpi: 120" >> ~/.Xresources

and be happy forever after (tested with i3wm, not sure with other environments which may do weird stuff to DPI handling like Plasma and GNOME)

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#194
> but the truth is that the built-in antimalware protection in Windows is simply horrible (according to various AV comparisons, Microsoft Essentials misses over 20% of in-the-wild malware)

AV comparisons have to be normally taken with a pile of salt. There's rarely an independent one. And even once you start looking at 3rd parties, it turns out they enable attack surface on their own. Then there's a number of 3rd parties which rely on cloud scanning aka "submit it to virustotal".

Here's some more context for why the comparisons are tricky: https://www.mrg-effitas.com/research/stop-using-virustotal-t...

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> File explorer freezes / crashes. It's been happening to me too, but it's unclear to me if it's one of my shell extensions or Windows itself. Do you run any shell extensions? > There are occasional glitches with git. It wouldn't let me clone a git repo somewhere because it said the folder already existed. No such folder existed. Changing the destination name did nothing. Restarting fixed it. That's mind-boggling. We…

> It's been happening to me too, but it's unclear to me if it's one of my shell extensions or Windows itself. Do you run any shell extensions? only shellex here is 7zfm integration and I get occasional explorer.exe crashes. Also I had an install where edge just wouldn't start. At all.

Good to know, thanks for the info! I do have 7-zip too, so I'll try to see if it might be related if it happens again.

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#196

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The relatively common (?) experience that: 1. Running `sudo apt update && sudo apt upgrade` is much, much faster than explicitly going to the windows update screen, checking for updates and then updating. 2. Linux OSs are usually stuck "updating" while shutting down and restarting, far less frequently and for a far shorter time (if at all), than Windows. Obviously the comparison isn't entirely fair (though in some wa…

Do you have any numbers for this? It doesn't match my experiences at all. Edit: it's been my experience that most people who think Windows sucks think this because they use it exclusively at work where their IT department has gone mad with power and turned off all the good stuff, and the network is slow.

> Do you have any numbers for this? It doesn't match my experiences at all.

Sorry, no, purely "anecdata", mainly based on a variety of personal and family laptops and desktop computers. There have been occasional IT department-managed update nightmares, but I don't count these.

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do your employee's systems need to be "Administrated" in the first place? Why do you need Active Directory or LDAP? Why do you need group policy or anything else? Why are your endpoints not as close to vanilla simple desktop/laptops as possible? Is it that employees can't handle using a computer? I've worked in one of the largest businesses in the world for many years now, and I don't think we even have an IT dep…

> Why do you need Active Directory or LDAP? Primarily authentication, authorization, and accounting[0]. Setting up a new user account on every single computer that an employee may at some point sit at gets very expensive. Many businesses (if not immediately then eventually) have security concerns that require Administrators have the ability to immediately lock users out of the system or be able to audit recent activi…

> Primarily authentication, authorization, and accounting[0]. Setting up a new user account on every single computer that an employee may at some point sit at gets very expensive

Why are people using more than one machine?

> Many businesses (if not immediately then eventually) have security concerns that require Administrators have the ability to immediately lock users out of the system or be able to audit recent activity.

Why are the network services tied to login sessions on my machine? I mean, login token invalidation is an interesting problem in general, but every place I’ve worked in the past 10 years, my desktop is not the place where secure things are stored, the services I access are. (And those services are increasingly SaaS and use something like SAML with the directory server for the company.) None of which needs a login token associated in any way with my desktop login.

Perhaps a better phrasing of the question is, why is the demarcation line between the untrusted world and the things you’re protecting on the desktop? And not at the services themselves?

> It can also automate standard settings like network drives, screen lockout settings, homepages, and all sorts of other settings.

Sounds like a bunch of solutions to problems you’re creating for yourselves. Why even do any of these things?

Perhaps an analogy would be helpful:

Say you required all your employees to have smart phones so they could (for instance) get email, log into the timecard/accounting service, etc. You’d need a pretty huge justification to require all of the phones to be managed centrally by your company. Why are desktops different?

(Or perhaps you’d defend even the central management of my iPhone too, in which case I think our perspectives are so far off, I don’t think there’s much convincing either of us can do at this point.)

I used to be an AD administrator for a university and had to manage hundreds of lab machines (maintaining a central hardware-independent image, group policy, tons of settings), so I’m aware of what tools are available for Administration, I’m just saying 9 times out of 10, the best way to administer lots of systems is to not administer them at all.

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#198
post #54

I've come to accept that there is no good OS (maybe iOS, but not really). You're just picking your poison. Want to be spied on and have your system slowly accumulate cruft and grind to a halt over the course of a few years? Use Windows. Want to be constantly fiddling with your system just to keep it running on a day to day basis? Use Linux. Want to be constantly spied on and probably also hacked? Use Android. Want to…

Just because some Linux users do that does not mean it is a requirement. If it were, Linux could never have achieved server the server dominance it has. Fiddling is a side effect of Linux being too flexible, so you always have the nagging feeling you could be better with a different distro/window manager/shell/editor/file manager.

I installed Linux Mint on my parents' computer and it's been running rock solid for three years. And they appreciate not being tricked into updates they don't want.

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this is inherently due to Windows registry and no enforced standards for Windows file system. In Linux, packages are generally reviewed to ensure they follow a set of practices to ensure that they use the appropriate directories. Then they simply have to extract the files/folders to install the application, and removing is as simple as deleting those directories/files. In Windows, you really never know what y…

I'll take the Windows Registry over an OS that litters my home directory with dot files, or even simply force me to create my own format of saving my settings (even ~/.settings is barely an improvement). Saving your settings should be an API offered by the OS and the Windows Registry is pretty good at that.

Have you looked in a Windows user's home directory?

Re: Why Windows 10 Sucks or Everything Wrong with Microsoft Windows

#200

I actually really like Windows 10, a huge portion of this list could easily apply to any modern operating system that isn't Linux, and even there some of it applies. So OSX, Android, iOS, etc. The section "Now the second kind of issues is intrinsic to Windows 10 only" is full of things that are literally applicable to all the OSes I listed above. I had some laugh out loud moments reading it. Are people just blinded b…

MacOS doesn't have 95% of the listed issues. And we don't have any other desktop OSes which are ready for prime time.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN