Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

ohmyperson.com

51–60 of 231 posts

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I challenge you to find a more succinct term that gets the same point across. “unattractive” a word you yourself already used. If you read the guidelines of the site, you’d understand the difference and why it’s important.

Ugly and unattractive aren't the same thing.

Then use “ugly”, rather than a pejorative term meant to ridicule. As an illustrative example, “ugly person” is to “uggos” as “fat person” is to “fatso”.

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#52

The "without pictures" concept is fine, but why did you choose to model the user profile after a CV? What do you think are the benefits over, say, OKC's approach?

When you can't rely on looks, what's the next best indicator? Money and social proof, obviously! Job history / relationship history is a reasonable proxy there, in the sense of other alternatives are worse.

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I challenge you to find a more succinct term that gets the same point across. “unattractive” a word you yourself already used. If you read the guidelines of the site, you’d understand the difference and why it’s important.

You don't get it. These are not the same thing. The difference, as others point out, is tone. One is far more formal than the other, and conveys a sense of stepping on eggshells. If the only way to discuss a concept is to first put on a suit and tie and pay prostrating deference to all who demand it (and demand it they will), then nobody will discuss it very much. This is how you win a game of censor-thy-neighbour wi…

See my reply to sibling comment. I’m not advocating for political correctness, I’m certainly the exact opposite of that more often than not. But I also feel it’s entirely unnecessary to shame people of a particular appearance in this context, “ugly people” is sufficiently specific to get the same point across you’re trying to make with “uggos”.

The fact you keep doubling down even after it was pointed out that you aren’t following the site guidelines is a strong indication you probably need to take a break, before one of the mods makes it a mandatory break.

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#54
I’ve thought about this a lot. I think it’s important that dating people match based on relative attractiveness, health, energy level, tidiness, age/maturity, mental attitude, goals and standard of living.

Also, dating sites should facilitate meeting, not pen-pals or “virtual” phony “relationships.”

Perhaps a more palatable way to approach this is to legitimately screen/curate each applicant and rate them honestly so that there’s less disappointment on blind matching. Also, you don’t what a Philip DeFranco moment of moving to NYC for a would-be significant other that is actually a 16-year-old con artist in Idaho.

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#55
post #30

Although I'm personally done with dating sites, I'm glad to see someone else had this idea, and actually made it. But please consider not making all data go through Google (analytics (which can be blocked) and firestore (which is required)) and allow logins without Google or Facebook accounts. Sharing browsing data of a dating site with a third-party should be considered a privacy issue.

> ... and firestore (which is required) ...

Ah. That's probably why it doesn't load for me.

I block local storage.

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#56
Looks are always a factor and some people on this site will find it out the hard way. Imagine being matched with someone on this website and chatting with them for a few weeks before meeting. If they ghost you after that meeting for your looks, it's going to be a lot more painful than being swiped left .

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#57

In 1 month: Dating Site Without Pictures, But With Voice Recording In 3 months: Dating Site With Pictures, But Only Of Eyes In 6 months: Dating Site With Pictures, Eyes and Nose In 12 months: name change to ohmymember.com (adult site)

13 months: profit

1 month: sells personal data of people with poor judgement: profit

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#58

I applaud the attempt to innovate in the dating world which tends to be solely focused on looks. But sexual attraction is an important part of relationships, so going in blind is inherently risky (from a time utilization perspective). With old school blind dates, your date is friend/family selected so some level of filtering is already done for you. I guess a good portion of dates are disappointing anyway and there a…

I vaguely recall computerized dating based on punched cards. I guess expectations have gone up.

Re: Show HN: Dating Site Without Pictures

#59
> "References: He was really nice to me, and one of the nicest guys I've ever dated. We had some issues with his parents not liking me, that eventually caused us to break up. but otherwise I'm envious of the next person who gets to be with him!"

The juxtaposition between dating and references.. doesn't work, at least to me. I can't imagine actually writing this about an ex. Especially, curious as to the circumstance in which this type of interaction would even occur. "Hey, sorry we didn't work out, now can you write a reference for my dating profile?"

Post reply on HN