Live data from Hacker News

U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

reuters.com

11–20 of 170 posts

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#11
post #9

I have watched hundreds of TikTok videos. The adults featured on the videos are less than 5%.

I think it's probably more for security reasons -- ie. they can be passing a dot map of all the Navy personnel around the world and their traveling patterns to the Chinese government.

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#12
post #9

I have watched hundreds of TikTok videos. The adults featured on the videos are less than 5%.

I think it's probably more for security reasons -- ie. they can be passing a dot map of all the Navy personnel around the world and their traveling patterns to the Chinese government.

That level of basic location data seems almost trivial, they probably don't even need you to install anything for that. I would expect the app feeds them far more data.

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#13
post #2

Since I’ve seen this asked elsewhere: There is a legitimate usage for these kinds of apps on some devices. Armed services recruiters tend to use various social media apps to communicate with people they are trying to recruit.

Someone likely did a risk/benefit analysis and the analysis didn’t come out in favor of the benefits. It’s probably that simple.

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#14
post #2

Since I’ve seen this asked elsewhere: There is a legitimate usage for these kinds of apps on some devices. Armed services recruiters tend to use various social media apps to communicate with people they are trying to recruit.

Someone likely did a risk/benefit analysis and the analysis didn’t come out in favor of the benefits. It’s probably that simple.

In the case of Tiktok, I agree. I’m just arguing for the class of apps in general (social media applications) not for TikTok.

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#16
post #3

This is silly. Do they allow any other social networking apps at all on government-issued phones? edit: tik tok makes sense for recruiting, and apparently it is currently used in the UK.

You obviously didn't read the article.

> ... Naval and Marine personnel who use government issued smart devices are generally allowed to use popular commercial apps, including common social media apps ...

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#18
post #9

I have watched hundreds of TikTok videos. The adults featured on the videos are less than 5%.

I think it's probably more for security reasons -- ie. they can be passing a dot map of all the Navy personnel around the world and their traveling patterns to the Chinese government.

Related (fitbit/strava leaking overseas military base layouts):

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/28/fitness-tracki...

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#19
post #7
post #3

This is silly. Do they allow any other social networking apps at all on government-issued phones? edit: tik tok makes sense for recruiting, and apparently it is currently used in the UK.

It would be hilariously tragic if a major government official used twitter for communication.

I think they all do now. You have to engage with people where the people are.

Re: U.S. Navy bans TikTok from government-issued mobile devices

#20
post #3

This is silly. Do they allow any other social networking apps at all on government-issued phones? edit: tik tok makes sense for recruiting, and apparently it is currently used in the UK.

> apparently it is currently used in the UK

There are various stories (the Daily Mail, Reuters, Times, please take your pick) that report that the Army is 'playing with' TikTok to see if it works in recruitment. Those same reports say it is being used by 'The Guards Division'.

The British Army doesn't have a 'Guards Division' [0]

[0] https://www.army.mod.uk/who-we-are/formations-divisions-brig...

Post reply on HN