Live data from Hacker News

Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

nbcnews.com

41–50 of 779 posts

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#41
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you further read the article, she went through the standard approval process for changes. She did it by the book. That's hardly "injecting code".

> Spiers, 21, said she went through the standard approval process, which requires two co-workers to greenlight changes, before updating the Chrome browser extension That sounds like code review approvals, not actual project/management approval of the 'feature'. We have the same: Cannot commit any code change unless 2 other team members have reviewed it. That has nothing to do with having actual project/management app…

Did you read what the extension is for?

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#42
post #7

>Kathryn Spiers, who worked as a security engineer, updated an internal Chrome browser extension so that each time Google employees visited the website of IRI Consultants — the Troy, Michigan, firm that Google hired this year amid a groundswell of labor activism at the company — they would see a pop-up message that read: “Googlers have the right to participate in protected concerted activities.” You should get fired…

Did you not read the part where she did, where she followed the process by the book and it was approved? Or did you just have your mind made up to decide to side with Google instead?

[deleted]

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#43
post #7

>Kathryn Spiers, who worked as a security engineer, updated an internal Chrome browser extension so that each time Google employees visited the website of IRI Consultants — the Troy, Michigan, firm that Google hired this year amid a groundswell of labor activism at the company — they would see a pop-up message that read: “Googlers have the right to participate in protected concerted activities.” You should get fired…

Did you not read the part where she did, where she followed the process by the book and it was approved? Or did you just have your mind made up to decide to side with Google instead?

This was the process: "the standard approval process, which requires two co-workers to greenlight changes"

In my company, I could put in travel orders to let me go to and from Hawaii on the company dime, have a vacation, and have my supervisor approve (which is following the standard process), but doing that should get me in a lot of trouble and/or fired.

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#44
post #20

Did no one read the article? > Spiers, 21, said she went through the standard approval process, which requires two co-workers to greenlight changes, before updating the Chrome browser extension. Another source at Google familiar with the update approval process confirmed to NBC news that those two approvals are standard practice for a browser extension update. She did it exactly according to internal policy. The exte…

I doubt thats the spirit of the rule. I would no more want that injected into my browser than any other political message.

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#45
post #16
post #5

> Kathryn Spiers, who worked as a security engineer, updated an internal Chrome browser extension so that each time Google employees visited the website of IRI Consultants — the Troy, Michigan, firm that Google hired this year amid a groundswell of labor activism at the company — they would see a pop-up message that read: “Googlers have the right to participate in protected concerted activities.” So basically, the Go…

If you further read the article, she went through the standard approval process for changes. She did it by the book. That's hardly "injecting code".

Seems like they need to rethink the book. I'm not sure a Googley culture of permissiveness can exist at the kind of scale that they have now, and with the competing activist factions that they have cultivated.

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#46
post #7

>Kathryn Spiers, who worked as a security engineer, updated an internal Chrome browser extension so that each time Google employees visited the website of IRI Consultants — the Troy, Michigan, firm that Google hired this year amid a groundswell of labor activism at the company — they would see a pop-up message that read: “Googlers have the right to participate in protected concerted activities.” You should get fired…

As noted later in the article, she got two thumbs up; doesn't this justify her actions .

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#47
post #7

>Kathryn Spiers, who worked as a security engineer, updated an internal Chrome browser extension so that each time Google employees visited the website of IRI Consultants — the Troy, Michigan, firm that Google hired this year amid a groundswell of labor activism at the company — they would see a pop-up message that read: “Googlers have the right to participate in protected concerted activities.” You should get fired…

Agreed, but the engineer's claim is that she followed the standard approval process "which requires two co-workers to greenlight changes". The article says another Googler confirmed that this is the process. But the article doesn't say that Spiers' assertion (that she went through the process, and had two colleagues sign off) has been specifically confirmed.

Presumably, audit logs would make this an easy thing to set straight.

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#49
post #20

Did no one read the article? > Spiers, 21, said she went through the standard approval process, which requires two co-workers to greenlight changes, before updating the Chrome browser extension. Another source at Google familiar with the update approval process confirmed to NBC news that those two approvals are standard practice for a browser extension update. She did it exactly according to internal policy. The exte…

And the popup message is one Google is required by law to make available to its employees.

Re: Engineer says Google fired her for notifying co-workers of right to organize

#50
post #3

> Kathryn Spiers, who worked as a security engineer, updated an internal Chrome browser extension > “We dismissed an employee who abused privileged access to modify an internal security tool,” a Google spokeswoman said in a statement, adding that it was “a serious violation.” The only times I’ve ever seen people fired quickly in Tech without a performance improvement plan or something similar is a security violation.…

one time i was fired for leaving my computer unlocked to go get some coffee. true story.

Military contractor?
Post reply on HN