Live data from Hacker News

Shopping Sucks Now

vice.com

171–180 of 230 posts

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#171
post #3

Anyone working on a Trader Joes meets Amazon? That curates maybe 1-3 versions of things, largely eliminating paradox of choice. I guess Costco is kind of a bulk version of that... Also I've been increasingly interested in just buying things once and having them last a decade+, ideally a lifetime (less waste). But this takes a lot of research. Trader Joes does a good job of curating groceries and I've come to trust th…

In 2006, I started a blogstore called "Reasonable Goods", and this was the whole premise. I got a Consumer Reports subscription and did a bunch of online research and tried hard to pick the one I thought would work well for ~80% of people in a bunch of categories. The first category was "toaster", and I found a decently-reviewed $20 basic toaster from a major manufacturer. I started using the tagline "It shouldn't take all day to buy a toaster".

For the one-year anniversary post, I decided to write a follow-up article on the toaster. That's when I discovered, in an ironic twist, that a half-dozen of our flagship pick had caught on fire during operation, and because of this the model had been recalled by the manufacturer.

That's when I realized that trying to find a commodity item that will last for a decade+ is impossible (these days anyway). The same model isn't manufactured for a decade, so you can't rely on history. Major manufacturers make mistakes and/or cut costs and/or sell their brand, so you can't rely on reputation. Even a top-3 recommendation from Consumer Reports did not prevent me from picking a lemon despite my sincere best effort to avoid it.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like you just hate people

I think it's more that some people want to purchase while others want to shop. Purchasing is a functional task while shopping is a social activity. Places like department stores are designed for shoppers.

I've never seen it put this way before. This exactly describes me - I enjoy purchasing. I don't enjoy shopping.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#173
post #169

Alright, startup idea: A service that, for a subscription fee, provides product reviews/recommendation lists, plus a concierge "recommend a product for my requirements" service. Maybe throw in basic troubleshooting help as well. All reviews and recommendations would come from staffers, so it can't be gamed with fake reviews short of bribing someone.

Try thewirecutter.com. It doesn't have a 'recommend' feature but the top picks in each category are usually the best value without hunting around.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#174
JCPenny opened a test store in Hurst TX, and its everything I miss about department stores, its brightly lit, it has a salon and a barbershop, the goods are displayed attractively and in an easy to find way - if all stores were like this one, I'd go shipping more often.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#175

When I was living in the PNW and realized I direly needed gloves, I just hit up a few of the department stores downtown until I found some that met my criteria. Which are probably similar to those of this author, I wanted some that looked cute, had a conductive patch on the finger so I could use my phone without taking them off, would fit on my long hands with long fingernails, and weren’t super expensive gloves desi…

I think the key to the article can be found in this passage: > [T]he problem is that now, somewhat suddenly, perfect knowledge of the perfect glove, for you specifically, exists, if you simply do enough research. When you're shopping in a physical store, you have no expectation that you're going to find the absolute, one-and-only perfect glove (or whatever) in the world for you. Even in the largest stores, you unders…

^+1 In just a few paragraphs, you summed up my frustration with online dating.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#176
post #123

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is especially weird when it's cheaper online on the SAME store. That happened with me in brazil.

What's worse is when the store won't honor their own online price. That happened to me in the US, I think it was Walmart.

They recently honored it for me. 20% difference.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#177

The perfect knowledge she claims to be burdened by is anything but. The actual problem here is imperfection of knowledge. What do you know, when someone tells you a glove is soft? What do you know, when they tell you it's waterproof? What do you know when they tell you it's leather? You know nothing for sure if all you've got to rely on is second-hand hearsay information. You're stuck in Plato's cave, chained to the…

Used to be brick an mortar stores had buyers. To get stuff on the shelf you needed to get past them. They were experts at evaluating products and would reject 'crap'. Now we have corrupt and easily gamed review processes and a race to the bottom.

Retail stores have sold their shelf space to the highest bidder for decades.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#178
post #161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Brandless makes no sense to me. They mostly buy from China and their products are more expensive than they should be (their product descriptions don't offer any arguments why, at least). They claim to be health and environmentally-conscious but there's no relevant information to read on the product pages. Take this random Brandless product: https://brandless.com/products/stainless-steel-wooden-turner Why on Earth wou…

Weird that "/products/stainless-steel-wooden-turner" doesn't seem to involve stainless steel at all.

The care instructions still mention that the handle is stainless steel. I suspect they’ve revised the design without creating a new SKU.

I do wonder why they felt the need to add metal at all though; I’ve never felt that a plain wooden spoon was lacking anything and having a heat-conductive material in a hot pot seems like a good way to get a burn. The description just says it’s a “nice accent.”

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#179
post #3

Anyone working on a Trader Joes meets Amazon? That curates maybe 1-3 versions of things, largely eliminating paradox of choice. I guess Costco is kind of a bulk version of that... Also I've been increasingly interested in just buying things once and having them last a decade+, ideally a lifetime (less waste). But this takes a lot of research. Trader Joes does a good job of curating groceries and I've come to trust th…

https://www.manufactum.com

I haven’t but anything from them but this seems to be their premise.

Re: Shopping Sucks Now

#180

When I was living in the PNW and realized I direly needed gloves, I just hit up a few of the department stores downtown until I found some that met my criteria. Which are probably similar to those of this author, I wanted some that looked cute, had a conductive patch on the finger so I could use my phone without taking them off, would fit on my long hands with long fingernails, and weren’t super expensive gloves desi…

You're talking about a pretty specific type of physical goods that have to fit properly and meet your requirements for aesthetics, quality, and function. Buying physical commodities or items where those factors don't matter on the Internet is incredible. I don't have to go anywhere, I don't have to talk to anyone, I don't have to lug anything anywhere, etc.

Did you read the article or go straight to the comments? I’m talking about buying the exact same thing the article used as an example. I think that’s a fair thing to contrast with its thesis that “all shopping sucks now”.

She had a terrible time spending days researching the Perfect Pair Of Gloves online, going to the one “big box” store in her area that had supposedly had it, and going back home ungloved instead of looking at other stores when the one store had no gloves in stock that day. I had a perfectly fine time going downtown when I was probably going there for some other reasons already and visiting a couple of stores looking for some Okay Gloves.

Post reply on HN