Live data from Hacker News

New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

cnn.com

451–460 of 480 posts

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#451

Wow, I can’t believe how dismissive most of the comments here are. The idea of adding folding wings to existing seat dimensions could be a huge, huge improvement for sleeping on flights. No, it’s not changing or solving anything else. Yes the model is tiny. No this isn’t solving existing recline issues if you’re 6’5”. If you have incredibly broad shoulders then you might not be able to use the wings but you can still…

Some of the statements in the article really weird me out though: > Who hasn't struggled to sleep on an airplane economy seat, forced to improvise a makeshift pillow out of a rolled up sweater or scarf? > A new seat design comes with an innovative solution to this inflight issue, using "padded wings" that fold out from behind both sides of the seat back -- allowing both for additional privacy and a cushioned spot to…

The last two international flights I've flown have already had small wings on the headrest. Not a big as the ones shown here, but useable at my height/size (5'7", 150lbs).

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#452

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The issue is how capitalism works. No one wants to pay a 1000$ for a domestic flight, but that's the only way you're getting personal space. Flights in the past were expensive, but comfortable. It's not a right to have space and affordability.

I'd pay $1000 for a domestic flight with leg room and a slightly wider seat. I flew first class out to San Diego recently and I would have done it on the way home as well but they wanted $2500 more for the same flight the other direction. That's just ridiculous. Flights in the past were never that expensive for the same comfort.

Dulles to O'hare (return fight) is ~$250-$300 economy. Business class is $600-$700. (both found using Google Flights)

So, you can already do what you want (get leg room and comfort for $1000 or less).

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#453

> The designers are considering adding facial recognition technology to the design. Um, what > In fitting with the trend towards more personalized, data-driven flying experiences, New Territory is keen to add facial recognition technology to the mix too. > The idea is that as the seat wing recognizes that you've fallen asleep, it'll automatically turn off the movie playing on your IFE. This could be the worst idea ev…

Just wait until they lobby the FAA to make this mandatory in all flights for your safety and make it a federal crime ti block the camera.

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#454

Wow, I can’t believe how dismissive most of the comments here are. The idea of adding folding wings to existing seat dimensions could be a huge, huge improvement for sleeping on flights. No, it’s not changing or solving anything else. Yes the model is tiny. No this isn’t solving existing recline issues if you’re 6’5”. If you have incredibly broad shoulders then you might not be able to use the wings but you can still…

I think you are just dismissing the fact that people have genuine grievances, even if they are not only not expressing themselves properly because they probably feel utterly powerless, but also because they likely don't quite understand how their own actions lead to the current situation. Is it not legitimate to point out that they either used an old looking 6 year old girl, photoshopped the heck out of that image, o…

Wouldn't a diversity initiative improve the situation for those of us that aren't height or width challenged?

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#455

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I call it the "Powerpoint nap". It's not just the interestingness, but the lack of engagement. When that meeting starts, your brain is likely shutting off the flow of orexin. That orexin may have been the only thing keeping you awake. You get bored or disengaged; you conk out. I'd guess, just from hearing that short description, that you don't get much natural sunlight in your workplace, the meetings are happening ju…

Seems a bit of a stretch to assume the guy has _sleep apnea_ if he nods off during a likely pointless meeting. If he's passing out at his desk, then perhaps.

I assume nothing. Sleep apnea is simply one of the most common sleep disorders, and one of the easiest to treat, so it makes sense to test it out first. The sleep study required to do so will also reveal most other sleep problems that are not caused by apneas.

Falling asleep involuntarily in the middle of the day is not normal, regardless of the circumstances. Sleep problems can lead to heart problems, and preventable deaths.

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#456
post #440

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nowhere in the article does it mention these are specifically for "premium" economy, these seats are, according to the article, supposedly meant for your run-of-the-mill economy cabin.

CNN is just wrong, though. These are being marketed as premium economy seats. https://thepointsguy.com/news/the-future-of-premium-economy/ https://runwaygirlnetwork.com/2019/12/10/wings-out-interspac... CNN got this wrong, and the rest of the major press is citing CNN as the source. But if you look, you can see that these seats are clearly not economy seats -- they're too wide, and they have all the premium economy t…

Don't blame me ;) Perhaps the user I replied to should have provided citations. I suspect you're not wrong, but neither of those two sources I'd recognise as "notable".

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#457
As someone who travels a lot long haul for work and always in economy. I highly recommend the J-Pillow. It solves one of the major problems of sleeping on flights which is that your chin drops forward and wakes you up. Also that you often get neck strain.

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#458

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But the intent isn't there for Amazon to listen to everything you say - which is why hotword detection is done locally on Alexa and only then is an audio stream sent to their servers.

I have a coworker who has Siri enabled on his phone. It regularly wakes up and starts recording seemingly at random. Maybe "always listening" isn't the correct phrasing. "It might be listening at any time" might be better.

Sure, but the intent is there to not do that.

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#459
post #298

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you serious? So now private entities have your facial information?

You do remember you've been showing your passport to these "private entitites" with your photo and personal details for decades?

Apples and oranges

Re: New airplane seat design to make it easier to sleep in economy

#460
post #395

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let's say this adds 10 pounds to each seat times 150-400 seats. No way the airlines would go for it they are trying to cut weight from the planes to scrape every ounce of fuel economy out of the airframe. It is a non-starter. Airlines also have zero incentive to increase passenger comfort because most airlines operate near capacity (all flights full/overbooked) on most routes because of deregulation. You have no alte…

> Airlines also have zero incentive to increase passenger comfort Airlines seem in a constant fight for passenger comfort to me! Some have as many as five cabin tiers, attempting to make as many people as comfortable as their budgets will allow. There's competition to make the most luxurious lounges. Out-fitting of power and WiFi seems to have been effective. Whole new aircraft like the 787 are designed with passenge…

> Airlines seem in a constant fight for passenger comfort to me!

Passenger comfort is what they like to talk about. That doesn't mean it's what they're really trying to optimize. They optimize for density too, but they're not about to advertise that. It's dangerous to mistake marketing for reality. So yeah, they'll add another cabin tier. Then they'll charge a fee for it and reduce the seat pitch elsewhere on their next order. It works really well when there are a few people who can pay for the upgrade out of their own pocket (most companies won't reimburse for it), but that's not really optimizing for comfort. And most people never get to use the lounges.

It's good to be one of those extra-revenue types, but when I take advantage of those things I'm keenly aware that I'm exercising a form of privilege. For most people, air travel isn't getting more enjoyable.

Post reply on HN