Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

zdnet.com

41–50 of 207 posts

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#41
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The penalty for trusting a stranger who shouldn't be trusted is much higher than the other way around.

In the world of for profit corporations I rather trust MS than any of the FAANG.

Why? I don’t trust F and G but the others are better than M to me.. Netflix has produced tons of widely used open source products for example...

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#42
post #22

For the hating Microsoft crowd, here are the projects where they are also using Rust, https://msrc-blog.microsoft.com/?s=rust And the talks done about the internal adoption, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qCB19DRw_60 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o01QmYVluSw And the author from C++/WinRT is now working on Rust/WinRT. https://kennykerr.ca/2019/11/05/rust/ So lets wait a bit before going to the castle with the pitch…

As a big proponent of F# it annoys me how much one still needs to fight "but M$" arguments if I point out a thing that F# does well. The same thing seems to happen when discussing Haskell with people who know just enough to recognise the influence MSR employees have on it.

It almost makes me wonder how they/we can work around that sentiment now. Either hope for generational shift to eventually kill it, or perhaps have them make a point of landing projects outside of MS and hoping nobody notices(GitHub R++ or whatever).

Tips on how others approach these discussions with Microsoft haters greatly appreciated!

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#44
post #17

Argh, they couldn't just contribute to the existing project.

Argh, you couldn't just take the time to read the actual article. "The ownership model in Verona is based on groups of objects, not like in Rust where it's based on a single object.

I did read that. So it's not a straight clone, but still, Rust has enough of an uphill battle as it is to reach wide adoption, without having its target market fragmented. So I would've been excited to see Microsoft embracing it instead of building a competitor. Not that I can necessarily judge them for that, but it's still disappointing.

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#45
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Argh, you couldn't just take the time to read the actual article. "The ownership model in Verona is based on groups of objects, not like in Rust where it's based on a single object.

I did read that. So it's not a straight clone, but still, Rust has enough of an uphill battle as it is to reach wide adoption, without having its target market fragmented. So I would've been excited to see Microsoft embracing it instead of building a competitor. Not that I can necessarily judge them for that, but it's still disappointing.

Having rust as the only low level language with ownership concept isn't ideal either.

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#46
post #45
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I did read that. So it's not a straight clone, but still, Rust has enough of an uphill battle as it is to reach wide adoption, without having its target market fragmented. So I would've been excited to see Microsoft embracing it instead of building a competitor. Not that I can necessarily judge them for that, but it's still disappointing.

Having rust as the only low level language with ownership concept isn't ideal either.

Sure, it's just that right now it's trying to bootstrap that category in the first place

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#47
post #2

Embrace, Extend, Extinguish.

Still living in the 2000s, I see.

Have you used windows recently? It sounds like you have. I installed it last week for the first time in ten-ish years - afraid I have to describe it as disgusting and completely undoing all the supposedly open work pr they've been getting. I'm on the phone so can't rant, but the install was endless info requests, some sneaky eg can we have your location, no, would you like us to find your device if stolen, erm. Open the browser, news thumbnails riddled with adverts. The timeline, extend beyond 30 days by giving us info. On and on. Sorry, they looked as though they had changed direction, but that surface laptop now runs Linux.

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#49
post #42
post #22

For the hating Microsoft crowd, here are the projects where they are also using Rust, https://msrc-blog.microsoft.com/?s=rust And the talks done about the internal adoption, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qCB19DRw_60 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o01QmYVluSw And the author from C++/WinRT is now working on Rust/WinRT. https://kennykerr.ca/2019/11/05/rust/ So lets wait a bit before going to the castle with the pitch…

As a big proponent of F# it annoys me how much one still needs to fight "but M$" arguments if I point out a thing that F# does well. The same thing seems to happen when discussing Haskell with people who know just enough to recognise the influence MSR employees have on it. It almost makes me wonder how they/we can work around that sentiment now. Either hope for generational shift to eventually kill it, or perhaps hav…

“Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me”

I try to be objective as much as possible, but having witnessed almost all of Microsoft’s behavior through history, we have been fooled 100s if not 1000s of times. How many times do you let the fox back into the hen house?

The only thing I think when I read recent “Microsoft is so great” comments is that the person is either too young to have any real knowledge, or they have simply not been paying attention for the past few decades.

For anyone who has seen what they have done through all of history, it will take decades to believe they have truly changed.

Re: Microsoft is creating a new Rust-based programming language for secure coding

#50
post #5

What does "Rust-based" even mean? Inspired by Rust? Does it transpile to Rust or something? Very confusing phrasing to me...

It’s described as a completely new thing, that borrows some ideas from Rust.
Post reply on HN