Live data from Hacker News

An Overview of Cryptography

garykessler.net

31–34 of 34 posts

Re: An Overview of Cryptography

#31
post #30
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right, especially since a few paragraphs down, he introduces all the different modes, including ECB.

To me at least, it makes sense to introduce a complex topic gradually, in stages. But regardless, I still agree that the wording in the paragraph you called out could be improved for better clarity.

Sorry to keep hammering on this, but ...

I don't know in what context it would be reasonable even as a simplification to say that block ciphers are semantically insecure like that. Anyone who listed that as a disadvantage to block ciphers should be regarded as confused, not speaking from a big picture perspective.

Furthermore, even if you're going to explain it that way as a result of building up the complexity gradually, you need to explicitly "unring" that bell, e.g. "Earlier I said X, but actually Y...". This author didn't.

Re: An Overview of Cryptography

#32
post #15

Shameless plug: I’ve been writing my own introduction for students/developers/consultants/... and you can read it online for free it seems (or at least some chapters): https://www.manning.com/books/real-world-cryptography

The Bleeding Edge section has much on the current status of post-quantum attempts?

Re: An Overview of Cryptography

#33
Side note: Diffie-Hellman predates RSA. I attended a talk by Rivest once, where he vividly described how that paper triggered them into exploring whether public key crypto was really possible or not. They ended up constructing RSA from those sessions.

Re: An Overview of Cryptography

#34
Holy smokes - I 'ran' into this website a few weeks ago whilst cleaning up an old computer.... and chuckled (my copy that I had saved on this computer is/was old - lets just say that).

And then I chance upon it being talked about on HN. Small world and maybe the universe is telling me something ;-)

Post reply on HN