Earlier quoted context omitted.
Purser acknowledges that Neale came up with the term in his book, and e.g. here: https://insighttimer.com/blog/ronald-purser-mcmindfulness-we... so I'm not sure that counts as hijacking. Especially as hijacking implies not retaining the original meaning of the word.
Purser mentions Neale once in the book then takes the word and the entire concept for his own use. I don’t want to be rude, but that’s the literal definition of hijacking.
McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
111–120 of 135 posts
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#112Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#113I apologize for the tangent, but: > Google engineers [are] working 60-70 hours a week - very stressful. Is this true? I worked a hard 35 hours a week when I was at Google. Granted, I was a junior engineer, but the fact that I could get away with that and have it not affect my career unduly always makes me surprised to hear descriptions of Google as a sweatshop. Can any Googlers say whether this has changed in the few…
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#114IMHO Daoist philosophy got it right and is the secret to removing stress and anxiety from almost everything. Daoist teachings have been adopted into traditional cognitive behavior therapy now called “dialectic behavioral therapy”
I learned this when I was in my 20s in college during huge bouts of depression and social anxiety and haven’t been depressed in 20 years.
My son who was recently suffering from social anxiety disorder was practically cured by it.
Strip down these mindfulness systems their simplest, and discard all the supernatural mumbo jumbo, incense burning, and ritual chanting. It’s easier to digest and remember.
If you just try to imagine that the past and future don’t really exist, that categories and divisions of reality are wholly created models of it by our mind, and that we can relinquish and let go and let negative thoughts or events wash over us like water, you can get a long way to ignoring most of the stress inducing phenomena in your life unless they are really salient.
At least that’s what’s worked form me. Should some starstuff on the pale blue dot really get worked up by wholly changeable and artificial deadlines? You can view them as important and plan for them yes, but don’t let your cortisol levels flare when things don’t go according to plans. Plans are changeable, life and health is more important.
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#115Earlier quoted context omitted.
You have a good citation for your first sentence, but not for your second.
It's like a religious person asking you to prove God isn't real. The science favoring meditation in general is shoddy (such as [0]), when a metaanalysis shows no evidence of a key claimed benefit to something, you'd want to be able to demonstrate a flaw in the metaanalysis. It's very much like acupuncture. Fake, but because it's steeped in tradition, people will fall for it. Many Westerners have really uninformed vie…
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#116Earlier quoted context omitted.
Purser mentions Neale once in the book then takes the word and the entire concept for his own use. I don’t want to be rude, but that’s the literal definition of hijacking.
No, the literal definition of hijacking is to forcibly commandeer a running vehicle.
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#117Clinical psychologist who teaches and practices mindfulness here. I often hear the argument that the current applications of mindfulness in corporate or otherwise commercial settings are a perversion of the original teachings. While to some extent it’s true that teachings have been adapted and the adaptations are sometimes (maybe often) problematic, the assertion that mindfulness training doesn’t belong in the boardr…
> Clinical psychologist who teaches and practices mindfulness here. The author has been practicing Buddhism for 4 decades. > the assertion that mindfulness training doesn’t belong in the boardroom seems silly to me But the author never makes this assertion. His point is that mindfulness training is hypocritical and inauthentic when used in a corporate environment.
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#118Earlier quoted context omitted.
No, the literal definition of hijacking is to forcibly commandeer a running vehicle.
The original definition of hijack refers to the seizure of goods in transit, typically contraband. Vehicles were involved as well, but it was really about prohibition booze. Exclusive application to vehicles didn’t come about until the mid-late 60s. Since then, it’s been applied to ideas, concepts, and even things like meetings and parties. Basically, taking things by force for other means.
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#119Earlier quoted context omitted.
It's like a religious person asking you to prove God isn't real. The science favoring meditation in general is shoddy (such as [0]), when a metaanalysis shows no evidence of a key claimed benefit to something, you'd want to be able to demonstrate a flaw in the metaanalysis. It's very much like acupuncture. Fake, but because it's steeped in tradition, people will fall for it. Many Westerners have really uninformed vie…
On [0], this "Meta-Analysis" was only for pro-social behavior and the longest study they looked at had people meditate for a total of only three months. You are right science does not have rigorous research to support some of claimed benefits of mindfulness meditation, but calling it fake and citing a sourc that starts its article by declaring meditation pseudoscience does not exactly seem rigorous either. I think th…
Re: McMindfulness: How mindfulness became the new capitalist spirituality
#120Research suggests Mindfulness increases empathy and reduces anger and fear. Wouldn’t reframing soldiers or CEOs worldview to be more compassionate galvanize more positive change than trying to convince Sundar Pichai or soldiers that they are bad people?