Live data from Hacker News

China's growing threat to academic freedom

japantimes.co.jp

11–20 of 64 posts

Re: China's growing threat to academic freedom

#11

> book of documents relating to 20th century Kuomintang Party history. Wondering what book it may be.

KMT is related to Taiwan even though they want closer ties to CCP

They , KMT, lost to the CCP in the civil war and fled to Taiwan.

Re: China's growing threat to academic freedom

#13
post #3

Stulta lex sed lex.

> Stulta lex sed lex. Latin for _stupid law but law_

It's a parody of a saying from the legal profession, "Dura lex sed lex" ("The law is harsh, but it is the law."), so the appropriate translation would be "The law is stupid, but it is the law."

Re: China's growing threat to academic freedom

#19
post #9
post #3

Stulta lex sed lex.

Given that there's no list of forbidden books, nor any realistic way of determining beforehand whether a specific book would be considered detrimental to China's security or otherwise would be illegal, is it actually a law? I am inclined to contrast it to what it's like in my own country. Canada, of course like every country, has a variety of laws that prohibit certain kinds of expression. The difference is that, whi…

Maybe. I recall shortly after sept 11th 2001 when there was general panic in the US, some guy there was arrested for possessing a book. He'd just taken it out of the library.

Here in the UK there are deliberate 'chilling effect' laws which are meant to discourage trying something by making them sufficiently unspecified as to catch anything the government wants to (heard about these on the radio 4 programme 'file on 4', it was about export restrictions).

Western governments are vastly better but they can do the same filthy tricks when it suits them.

Post reply on HN