Live data from Hacker News

Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

japantimes.co.jp

21–30 of 157 posts

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#21
Japan is a pretty good cautionary tale for Britain (and to a lesser extent to the US) on how shutting yourself off from immigration tends to go.

Japan was expected to become the next global superpower in the 1980s, and instead has seen closing in on three lost decades.

It’s only now trying to catch up, politically, culturally and economically.

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it's a valid choice for a country to decide that the economic boon from foreign entrepreneurs isn't worth it if those people can't speak your language. I'd certainly be irritated if someone opened a business in my town and couldn't speak English, and the US is a lot less homogeneous than Japan.

So, I don't understand this perspective at all. Help me get it. It seems to me that speaking a language is a skill. I know from my own experience trying to learn a second language that it isn't an easy skill for many people to acquire. Why should I be more irritated that someone doesn't speak English than that they, say, can't make a cabinet or can't write Java, or any other mildly demanding skill? I get the argument…

Making cabinets and speaking the language of a culture that is necessary to succeed are not the same thing at all. Yes they are both skills but the similarity ends there.

Do you think a Japanese person who doesn’t speak English could build a successful company in the US without the help of someone who speaks English? It would be impossible.

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#24
Japan doesn't want an influx of foreigners and rightfully so. It is a total failure in any nation state where they tried this experiment. Everybody declare that "diversity is our strange" but there is no proof for it at all, it is almost like a religious mantra that people mumble in order to justify the mess they have created. I used to believe this bullshit until I had the chance to live in Japan and to experience the huge advantages in an homogenous cohesive society.

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#25

Japan is a pretty good cautionary tale for Britain (and to a lesser extent to the US) on how shutting yourself off from immigration tends to go. Japan was expected to become the next global superpower in the 1980s, and instead has seen closing in on three lost decades. It’s only now trying to catch up, politically, culturally and economically.

Except the US has been pretty open to immigration for the last 250 years, while Japan is 98% Japanese.

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#26

Like others have stated, the Japanese are very much xenophobic to outsiders. The idea of bringing a business to Japan seems unique but you aren't going to get any community support like you would in western countries. Personally I view Japan has a oddity. A first world country that short of some tech and Toyota/Honda produce little to nothing for trade. Everything is imported which could land you into the red if the…

> A first world country that short of some tech and Toyota/Honda produce little to nothing for trade. Everything is imported

Japan does not export "some tech and Toyota/Honda". It exports a LOTS of vehicles, vehicle parts, integrated circuits, machines, etc. Japan is the 4th largest exporter in the world.

Also, a country that doesn't export much cannot import much, or else how could the country afford it?

edit: typo

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#28

Japan is a pretty good cautionary tale for Britain (and to a lesser extent to the US) on how shutting yourself off from immigration tends to go. Japan was expected to become the next global superpower in the 1980s, and instead has seen closing in on three lost decades. It’s only now trying to catch up, politically, culturally and economically.

The global superpower fears were wild exaggerations. They didn’t have the pop (workers and also consumers) to support those claims.

Of course contributing to those fears was vast underinvestment in modernization by US firms which were still relying on very old and inefficient technologies, so of course to some stateside companies (and “pundits”) they looked like worldbeaters.

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#29

Japan is a pretty good cautionary tale for Britain (and to a lesser extent to the US) on how shutting yourself off from immigration tends to go. Japan was expected to become the next global superpower in the 1980s, and instead has seen closing in on three lost decades. It’s only now trying to catch up, politically, culturally and economically.

As someone who lived in both countries I will take Japan any day over Britain. I wish Japan will not get tempted to do the mistakes Britain has done, if anything Britain should be a caution to Japan about the disaster that is looming for them if they open their country to immigration. The reason Japan didn't become a global power is because of it's size and size of population, they are still doing very well only without all the "enrichment" that Britain has to deal with.

Re: Japan wants foreign entrepreneurs, but what's missing?

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, I don't understand this perspective at all. Help me get it. It seems to me that speaking a language is a skill. I know from my own experience trying to learn a second language that it isn't an easy skill for many people to acquire. Why should I be more irritated that someone doesn't speak English than that they, say, can't make a cabinet or can't write Java, or any other mildly demanding skill? I get the argument…

Making cabinets and speaking the language of a culture that is necessary to succeed are not the same thing at all. Yes they are both skills but the similarity ends there. Do you think a Japanese person who doesn’t speak English could build a successful company in the US without the help of someone who speaks English? It would be impossible.

I'm not sure why you believe the similarity ends there. The Japanese person would likely do the same thing I do if I need a cabinet made-- hire someone with that skill to do the job. Eventually that might stop making economic sense and they might decide to cut out the middleman, but again-- I'm not sure why I should be irritated either way.
Post reply on HN