Live data from Hacker News

New York City is a mall

ny.curbed.com

1–10 of 57 posts

Re: New York City is a mall

#2
Manhattan has been turning into a mall for at least the last 20 years or so, starting with Times Square and radiating outward from there. That this has metastasized into more actual malls is not really surprising.

Re: New York City is a mall

#3
A good mall really is designed to be like a city. It's an interesting comparison. I noticed the same thing when I moved to Manhattan from the suburbs. Not just the proximity to retail stores (I live a half a block away from a Lululemon), but the dedication to a shared public space, and being around so many other pedestrians.

Re: New York City is a mall

#4
FWIW I live in Manhattan and I actively avoid these places. They are mostly packed with tourists, I doubt many locals spend time there. I've never been to Hudson Yards intentionally (I've walked past it before) and I don't plan on going. There's lots of good stuff in NYC if you're not a tourist, and it's very far from being a mall.

Re: New York City is a mall

#8
post #4

FWIW I live in Manhattan and I actively avoid these places. They are mostly packed with tourists, I doubt many locals spend time there. I've never been to Hudson Yards intentionally (I've walked past it before) and I don't plan on going. There's lots of good stuff in NYC if you're not a tourist, and it's very far from being a mall.

Many people like them. I was raised in NY and appreciate all the things NY has to offer, even the "touristy" ones. You should go!

Re: New York City is a mall

#9
I have to say that I feel bad for New Yorkers. I live in the middle of the country, but I work for a company on the lower east-side. I’m often in Manhattan, so I think I have a feel for what it’s like there and there is such a poverty of what a global city could be there. I’ve seen quite a bit of the world and dense Spanish urban centers are much better than Manhattan. Barcelona has created super blocks, which are these dense areas where absolutely no cars are allowed. The result is nothing short of amazing. The first time I saw it, I realized I had never seen anything like it before. There such an abundance of life and the levity in the air is palpable. “This is what it must have been like to live in an ancient city“ is often what I found myself thinking. Your really need to experience it before you die. It’s what human life should look like. New York ain’t it. Not even close.

Re: New York City is a mall

#10
post #6

I would be glad to see farmers markets and public green space with living plants and places for children to play freely displace them all.

Would it work economically though? Are there enough farmers and demand for products to make it commercially viable in manhattan?
Post reply on HN