Live data from Hacker News

Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

bleepingcomputer.com

31–40 of 448 posts

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#31
post #19

Classic cat and mouse moves. Adblockers will move to OS level so google cant do anything about it. Pi-hole and Network level blockers should also see a rise.

DNS-based blocking schemes lack fine grained control. They're simply less capable than uBlock Origin/uMatrix.

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#32
post #19

Classic cat and mouse moves. Adblockers will move to OS level so google cant do anything about it. Pi-hole and Network level blockers should also see a rise.

Pi-hole can't filter out ads that are embedded into the page though. I think adblockers have to be a browser extension to work conprehensively.

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#33
post #12
post #4

time to move to firefox

Way ahead of you...

I moved earlier this year, it's been a good experience overall. The dev tools, which were what was holding me back, are _excellent_ and improving all the time.

Only thing I'd really love to see are container-specific windows, so 'Work' tabs would open by default in my 'Work' window.

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#35

I wonder how much of this is actually about Adblockers... vs Googlers just wanting to make some performance numbers go up in aggregate to make their own internal company stats better. Cos sure as hell no user is waiting for this.

Apple/Safari adopted pretty much the same architecture on Ad Blockers. Maybe just maybe the conspiracy theories are all wrong, and there was actually a legitimate, technical reason for choosing a restricted API.

Google is an advertisement company there is nothing conspiratorial about them using their market share to force ads on people. After all whats the point of supporting chrome if it sells no adds.

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#37

I wonder how much of this is actually about Adblockers... vs Googlers just wanting to make some performance numbers go up in aggregate to make their own internal company stats better. Cos sure as hell no user is waiting for this.

Apple/Safari adopted pretty much the same architecture on Ad Blockers. Maybe just maybe the conspiracy theories are all wrong, and there was actually a legitimate, technical reason for choosing a restricted API.

Safari's limit is significantly higher, and bluntly nobody is using Safari because they think it gives them user freedom.

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#38
post #15

This is the point in the dominance cycle where the dominant player decides they no longer need to be the fastest or the most secure and that their dominance will allow them to coast along doing their thing. There’s nothing particularly inevitable about what happens next, but let’s hope they get an IE6-sized kick in the teeth.

Many many people use adblockers now. The amount of users they will alienate would be very high.

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#39
On mobile i use brave, and when things break I switch to chrome. I tried Firefox multiple times, but I can't help but miss the swipe the address bar to go from tab to tab. I always revert back to chrome. So it's more of a convenience for me.

But if I had to choose between adblock or swipe to switch tab, then they made the decision for me. There is no way I can ever browse the web without an adblocker

Re: Google Begins Testing Extension Manifest V3 in Chrome Canary

#40

On mobile i use brave, and when things break I switch to chrome. I tried Firefox multiple times, but I can't help but miss the swipe the address bar to go from tab to tab. I always revert back to chrome. So it's more of a convenience for me. But if I had to choose between adblock or swipe to switch tab, then they made the decision for me. There is no way I can ever browse the web without an adblocker

...But mobile chrome doesn't support extensions anyway?

I use Blokada for adblocking on Android btw, and this change wouldn't affect that. Works fine.

Post reply on HN