Live data from Hacker News

Intel publishes misleading benchmarks against AMD

servethehome.com

11–20 of 209 posts

Re: Intel publishes misleading benchmarks against AMD

#11
Yes, synthetic benchmark results in general are to be taken with a grain of salt, leaving a lot of potential for things like these that can easily produce the result you desire than what really is.. there is a big question of how this translates to what your workload needs/does.

We just bought our first AMD Epyc server for our HPC cluster. I cant wait until next week to test it against our Skylake nodes. 1 socket EPYC 16C cpu vs 2X Xeon Skylake. I already have a suite of our internal workloads to hammer them with.. one of them is a key in house software compiled usually with intel compiler and intel mkl for performance reasons. Really curious how it will do with the EPYC cpus.

Re: Intel publishes misleading benchmarks against AMD

#15
The value proposition with AMD's current offerings is staggering. I didn't know computers would be this good this soon.

The one thing I'm not pleased with is the general poor experience with integrators, on both platforms. Who told them they shouldn't put prices on gigabyte.com? I see the actual price on a distributor's site and I'm nothing but pleased.

Re: Intel publishes misleading benchmarks against AMD

#16
post #4

I recall a few months ago they released a marketing pack benchmarking themselves against AMD with a small print disclaimer that they hadn't applied the spectre/meltdown fixes.

Many applications don't need Spectre or Meltdown mitigations, but they should at least put the test parameters up front and not in the fine print.

Re: Intel publishes misleading benchmarks against AMD

#20
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All benchmarks are misleading.

Could you expand on that please

The search space has many, many dimensions--CPU, MMU, OS implementation details, how well the compiler translated source to machine code for that particular CPU, how well did the benchmark implementation cater to the target architecture, etc, etc.

Immense opportunities to fool others, and even yourself.

Post reply on HN