Live data from Hacker News

New drug forces flu virus into ‘error catastrophe,’ overwhelming with mutations

sciencemag.org

1–5 of 5 posts

Re: New drug forces flu virus into ‘error catastrophe,’ overwhelming with mutations

#2
"Even though sequencing clearly shows the virus trying to resist the drug, no resistant strains developed."

I don't understand how that works. How does it "try" to resist? Isn't this all-or-nothing to the virus? Either it reproduces or it doesn't?

Re: New drug forces flu virus into ‘error catastrophe,’ overwhelming with mutations

#3
post #2

"Even though sequencing clearly shows the virus trying to resist the drug, no resistant strains developed." I don't understand how that works. How does it "try" to resist? Isn't this all-or-nothing to the virus? Either it reproduces or it doesn't?

They mutate. 'Resist' implies intent which they don't have. But they mutate when they reproduce. Some mutations will given them drug resistance but they haven't lucked into them yet.

Re: New drug forces flu virus into ‘error catastrophe,’ overwhelming with mutations

#5
post #3
post #2

"Even though sequencing clearly shows the virus trying to resist the drug, no resistant strains developed." I don't understand how that works. How does it "try" to resist? Isn't this all-or-nothing to the virus? Either it reproduces or it doesn't?

They mutate. 'Resist' implies intent which they don't have. But they mutate when they reproduce. Some mutations will given them drug resistance but they haven't lucked into them yet.

If this formulation encourages mutations, doesn't that feel like it will play right into your described method of lucking into resistance?