Live data from Hacker News

Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

abovethelaw.com

21–30 of 62 posts

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#21
post #19
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unlikely, courts tend to take a dim view on religions that aren't several hundreds if not thousands of years old. It is a legal hack to prevent situations like the one you described.

Doesn't Scientology have the status of an accepted religion in the US?

They got an exception because of the all the rich/famous people they have.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He made it pretty clear it was self-depreciative humour. If this blog post actually offended you, instead of merely making you think that others might be offended, then I suggest that you lighten up a bit.

I'm offended by such bad writing.

Unprofessional and bad aren't the same thing.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He made it pretty clear it was self-depreciative humour. If this blog post actually offended you, instead of merely making you think that others might be offended, then I suggest that you lighten up a bit.

I'm offended by such bad writing.

And I'm offended by your general lack of humor and dismissal of the merits of the article (which I did not find that enjoyable) based on something so trivial. I used to think that commenting on HN could not hurt your career, but the smug attitude you displayed (ie: your answer towards nowarninglabel) could be an indication that I'm wrong. C'est la vie.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#24
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn't Scientology have the status of an accepted religion in the US?

They got an exception because of the all the rich/famous people they have.

So the defining characteristic of a religious entity is how much that entity can extort from its followers, and because Scientology extorts from the rich rather than the poor they attained this status faster.

Now where's my chapel in the Apple Store? I suppose the Genius Bar may constitute, but I'm smarter than those people so it doesn't provide me any solace.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#25
This makes me think of Weird Al's "White and Nerdy"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9qYF9DZPdw

I attended a military academy, which mildly resembled prison in a few respects. We weren't allowed out of the dorms after 7pm, and an instructor would make sure we were all in bed (checking off our names on a checklist) and turn the light out in our rooms for us. Then he'd stay there and make sure we didn't leave our rooms until just before Reveille.

The jocks and bad atitude cases would sometimes dress up as commandos in all-black outfits and go on "missions" to sneak off have trysts with girlfriends or pull pranks (like shining the breasts of one female statue on campus.) They'd often get caught, which was bad because it was technically a dismissal offense. Me, I was part of a group that snuck around after lights out to gather and play D&D. Actually, we didn't sneak. We just put on dress uniform, and the security guards assumed we were Officer of the Day.

No, I did not have a girlfriend in High School.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#26

Personally, I think the reasoning is completely bogus, however, I'm all for not allowing people to spend their day playing D&D while I and other tax payers pay for it (and I'll expand the D&D to anything that does not fall in the restitution or rehabilitation buckets). On the other hand, I could see D&D being a good rehabilitation tool. Personal rant aside, D&D sure seems like it would be a LOT better than some thing…

One of my bosses got a lot of his "think on your feet" chops from D&D. He was damn good. No one ever caught him flat footed without an answer and all of his answers sounded good and scored a point for his side. I asked him once where it came from, and he told me it was playing D&D.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#28

Personally, I think the reasoning is completely bogus, however, I'm all for not allowing people to spend their day playing D&D while I and other tax payers pay for it (and I'll expand the D&D to anything that does not fall in the restitution or rehabilitation buckets). On the other hand, I could see D&D being a good rehabilitation tool. Personal rant aside, D&D sure seems like it would be a LOT better than some thing…

You probably should rephrase "some things I've read about in prison." I don't think you meant what it expresses.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#29

Personally, I think the reasoning is completely bogus, however, I'm all for not allowing people to spend their day playing D&D while I and other tax payers pay for it (and I'll expand the D&D to anything that does not fall in the restitution or rehabilitation buckets). On the other hand, I could see D&D being a good rehabilitation tool. Personal rant aside, D&D sure seems like it would be a LOT better than some thing…

One of my bosses got a lot of his "think on your feet" chops from D&D. He was damn good. No one ever caught him flat footed without an answer and all of his answers sounded good and scored a point for his side. I asked him once where it came from, and he told me it was playing D&D.

I learned a lot from playing D&D as well -- my interest in graphic/info design can be traced back to when I was designing my own charts and character sheets.

Re: Dungeons & Dragons ruled a threat to prison security

#30
this is irrelevant topic, for one, and it's also irrelevant in terms of even getting a voice! Once you go to prison for what this guy did (1st degree murder with a sledge hammer) your rights are no more. And when you have no rights, you don't even have a voice on the matter. You are to rot the rest of your fcking life in a jail cell. (period)
Post reply on HN