Live data from Hacker News

Boeing Engineers Lost Control of the Company

perell.com

231–234 of 234 posts

Re: Boeing Engineers Lost Control of the Company

#231
post #230
post #224

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This assumes Boeing had a priori knowledge that the system would cause a crash. The fact that the system safety analysis didn't label it 'catastrophic' seems to indicate they didn't know this. This doesn't absolve them of the responsibility that they should have, or that they still didn't follow their design procedures stating redundant senaors

“I didn’t KNOW removing three of the four brakes on my car would cause a crash” is an argument you could make. I wouldn’t want to stake my freedom on it.

That's assuming you are making a connection between brakes and a catastrophic failure.

The fact the system safety analysis didn't call out an MCAS failure as catastrophic seems to indicate they misunderstood the system risk which is different than claiming a catastrophic failure is an acceptable risk

Re: Boeing Engineers Lost Control of the Company

#232
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I love seeing these false statements on HN, where most users have no idea what the aerospace industry is like.

The Boeing people that I work with are not allowed to travel.

Some still do. I suspect you only know a very small percentage of the total number of employees.

Re: Boeing Engineers Lost Control of the Company

#233
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i have quite the video for you (timestamped, but the whole thing is worth watching): https://youtu.be/rvkEpstd9os?t=2499

That documentary is very naive. This is a good review: https://www.forbes.com/sites/airchive/2014/09/10/review-al-j...

[deleted]

Re: Boeing Engineers Lost Control of the Company

#234
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i have quite the video for you (timestamped, but the whole thing is worth watching): https://youtu.be/rvkEpstd9os?t=2499

That documentary is very naive. This is a good review: https://www.forbes.com/sites/airchive/2014/09/10/review-al-j...

this is weak industry pr. the fact is that boeing did not have safety issues before finance took over, and that opening a non-union shop for the purpose of labor fungibility is going to result in less experienced workers with a lower stake on average. it doesn't even bother mentioning what i linked, which is that 2/3 of the informally surveyed employees lack confidence in the final product to the point that they wouldn't want their families to fly on the planes.
Post reply on HN