Live data from Hacker News

LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

legoos.io

11–20 of 83 posts

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#11
Alternate names: BlocksOS, DistrOS, DistribOS,BuildOS

I'd suggest cloning the repo locally, as when this gets TOS'd for obvious trademark issue, Github's deletion won't hit your local machine (but will also nuke forks on GH).

Cool project, poor choice in name.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#12

Incoming DCMA takedown notice in 3... 2.... (seriously though, Lego is famous for being bulldogs in regards to their trademark/brand!)

As DMCA stands for Digital Millennium Copyright Act, trademarks are outside its scope. There have actually been successful counterclaims under section 512(f) against companies using the DMCA to police trademark infringement. All that said, an old-fashioned cease and desist letter from Lego is most certainly incoming.

Ah - TIL ... thanks for a solid response =)

Either way - I'd avoid using someone's brand unless it was changed up in a MAJOR way.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#13

LEGO have a very friendly[1] explanation that they must pursue legal action to protect their trademark internationally. They have rules about using their trademark in names, logos, websites and URLs. [1] https://www.lego.com/en-sg/legal/notices-and-policies/fair-p...

I think they broke just about every single one of LEGO®'s rules in the trademark section.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#14
post #8
post #7

So, actually reading the paper. What it appears that they are doing is blowing up the concept of a 'server' entirely, and replacing the system bus with network. So you can have a bunch of 'servers' racked together which create a pool of cpus, ram, storage, and so on, all of which are connected by the network. And then they pull from this pool of resources to create vNodes which are like virtual machines. I like the i…

> What it appears that they are doing is blowing up the concept of a 'server' entirely, and replacing the system bus with network. So you can have a bunch of 'servers' racked together which create a pool of cpus, ram, storage, and so on, all of which are connected by the network. And then they pull from this pool of resources to create vNodes which are like virtual machines. Sounds to me a lot like a Beowulf cluster,…

wow! blast from the past! last time i setup a b/w cluster was as an experiment some 12-14 years ago!

I was thinking this sounds like how DCOS presents resources; buckets of cpu, ram, disc, etc.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#15

Incoming DCMA takedown notice in 3... 2.... (seriously though, Lego is famous for being bulldogs in regards to their trademark/brand!)

As DMCA stands for Digital Millennium Copyright Act, trademarks are outside its scope. There have actually been successful counterclaims under section 512(f) against companies using the DMCA to police trademark infringement. All that said, an old-fashioned cease and desist letter from Lego is most certainly incoming.

Honestly, I would rather get an email from my hosting company saying my project has been taken down after receiving a DMCA notice than get a visit from a process server saying that a huge corporation has filed a suit against me.

Not having a DMCA for trademark means that the process server is very, very likely to knock on your door for naming something after Lego.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#16
I don't see how this is any different compared to Beowulf, Mosix, Amoeba and other mass-machine boundary-eliminating systems that were attempted back in the 90s. Am I missing something that makes this better suited to the task of resource utilization across nodes?

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#17

LEGO have a very friendly[1] explanation that they must pursue legal action to protect their trademark internationally. They have rules about using their trademark in names, logos, websites and URLs. [1] https://www.lego.com/en-sg/legal/notices-and-policies/fair-p...

I think they broke just about every single one of LEGO®'s rules in the trademark section.

When I first read LegoOS, I thought it was an OS made by Lego. I wouldn't be unreasonable considering that they have a software platform with the Mindstorm line.

The fact that confusion is possible goes against the spirit of the trademark law.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#18

LEGO have a very friendly[1] explanation that they must pursue legal action to protect their trademark internationally. They have rules about using their trademark in names, logos, websites and URLs. [1] https://www.lego.com/en-sg/legal/notices-and-policies/fair-p...

Thank you for citing this. LEGO is notorious for protecting their trademark. It was a really silly name to use and they will definitely get a C&D quickly.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#19
post #3

Wouldn't this be a copyright infringement?

Trademark infringement. They could argue it is a different category than the toy company, but I think that line of argument is already lost given they are using LEGO style bricks on the website.

> They could argue it is a different category than the toy company, but I think that line of argument is already lost given they are using LEGO style bricks on the website

It helps that it is a different product. They could put down Pikachu iconography and that doesn't make the product similar to Pikachu. All colored bricks are not (yet) under Mattel's control. I think there's wiggle room.

Re: LegoOS: A Disseminated, Distributed Operating System

#20

LEGO have a very friendly[1] explanation that they must pursue legal action to protect their trademark internationally. They have rules about using their trademark in names, logos, websites and URLs. [1] https://www.lego.com/en-sg/legal/notices-and-policies/fair-p...

I think they broke just about every single one of LEGO®'s rules in the trademark section.

And here I thought it was a spin on that elf in LTOR.
Post reply on HN