Live data from Hacker News

Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

aws.amazon.com

151–160 of 471 posts

Re: Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

#151
post #148

Is "Amazon's Consumer Area" deliberately specific? That is, are they still using Oracle somewhere else? (Despite 75 petabytes being significant) Edit: I did see "some third-party applications are tightly bound to Oracle and were not migrated" . Curious if that's all that is left, globally, at AMZN.

There are Oracle AWS offerings - https://aws.amazon.com/oracle/

Re: Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In 2001/2003, I led a small team at an agency that converted Kraftfoods and 50+ brands from 25+ ATG Dynamo web/app CMS servers + 20+ Oracle servers to .NET 1.0 CMS on 3 web servers, 3 app servers and 3 Microsoft SQL Servers. Even then Oracle tools were horrible for developers and still are. The only reason they had that many databases was Oracle's business is licensing, massive, expensive licenses, and their sales pu…

Oracle's new licensing requirement for Java is a bit threat to that platform. My company for technical reasons can't switch to OpenJVM so we're going to pay Oracle their new licensing money but we're not doing any greenfield Java development and are going to work towards moving our Java applications to another platform. That's an n=1 example but wouldn't be surprised if others end up migrating away, causing longterm…

> My company for technical reasons can't switch to OpenJVM

The OpenJDK (not 'OpenJVM', that's not a thing) is literally 100% the same build as Oracle JDK now. There can't be any technical reason.

Re: Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

#153
post #148

Is "Amazon's Consumer Area" deliberately specific? That is, are they still using Oracle somewhere else? (Despite 75 petabytes being significant) Edit: I did see "some third-party applications are tightly bound to Oracle and were not migrated" . Curious if that's all that is left, globally, at AMZN.

There are Oracle AWS offerings - https://aws.amazon.com/oracle/

Good example of what I'm asking for. Does AMZN use any Oracle RDS, or other Oracle offerings, aside from what they just retired?

Re: Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

#155
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m interested in seeing how much they try to milk Java in the next 10 years. I can see them getting desperate enough to really bring the hammer down on licensing, killing off openjdk, and making life miserable for everyone in the process.

How? Its an Open source implementation of the java vm which they don't own.

> which they don't own

They do own it. They own the copyright on the source code (all of it - even if Google or Intel wrote it). They own the trademarks. They own the specifications.

Re: Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

#156

It should be noted that the email that Steve Yegge made famous was: 1) The birth of the service oriented architecture as a standard at Amazon 2) Took place long before AWS was used by Amazon's commercial business, and most software systems were monolithic, requiring mainframe-like dedicated hardware. 3) Was inspired due to the epic spaghetti monster known as FC Software, whose entire non-architecture revolved around…

I dunno about that. Maybe this could be read as a success story. They built half-assed software quickly, scaled it to ridiculous levels, made billions of $, and finally had to replace it with something better. And now they are just fine.

Re: Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

#158

The video feels like a big middle finger to Oracle. "stop oracle", and the URL https://aws.amazon.com/products/databases/freedom . Not that I'm complaining, Oracle deserves all the hate they get for their business practices. But associating AWS with "breaking free" is extremely ironic. It's just as much of a source for vendor lock in as Oracle. If you are not extremely careful/dedicated with your system design, you a…

I guess the only freedom is that of multi-year license contracts.

Re: Amazon’s Consumer Business Turned Off Final Oracle Database

#160

It should be noted that the email that Steve Yegge made famous was: 1) The birth of the service oriented architecture as a standard at Amazon 2) Took place long before AWS was used by Amazon's commercial business, and most software systems were monolithic, requiring mainframe-like dedicated hardware. 3) Was inspired due to the epic spaghetti monster known as FC Software, whose entire non-architecture revolved around…

> The oracle database functioned as a database, but also as a high throughput queue, as well as a message passing platform. At high loads, different applications were hitting the same rows so frequently that the transaction errors alone could bring down an entire fulfillment center. Isn't that how everyone uses Oracle? I've seen exactly the same complains from developers at banks. Although building software around bi…

I've seen the same architecture implemented in MSSQL and MySQL. It's pretty easy to paint yourself into a corner where your one database is doing all sorts of stupid things because you never sat down and identified the problem space in the larger context and moved to a wider configuration instead of simply using a table with short-lived rows as a queue. It's the same arguments about nails and hammers.
Post reply on HN