Live data from Hacker News

Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

netblocks.org

171–180 of 256 posts

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#171
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Stick to facts please.

In a war situation you don't have access to facts until after the dust has settled and the bad things have happened, so two years from now I will revise my assessment of the situation based on "the facts". The facts we do have available are historical record of what happens when self-interested, oppression happy Turkish dictators decide that a group of people are terrorists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_Genocide

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#172
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stick to facts please.

We don't know the facts. This absolutely might be leading to genocide. The fact that they are cutting social media is even more evidence it might go in that direction.

You referring BBC as a safe source. I offer you to watch this whole video. You may see how prejudiced BBC is.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdRIr0QFOqk

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#173
post #6
post #4

> Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey It's kind of incredible how that head line are so terrifying. The only explanation for this is that people don't want information getting out of that area. It's so fucked up. Maybe this is a bit naive to say but I really hate that this is just how things are. We all know what's going to happen and there's nothing that can be done about it. It d…

Wouldn't Starlink by Space X solve this? Authoritarian govs. would make it illegal to subscribe... but like VPNs it would be very hard to police, even harder.

We don't need Starlink or SpaceX or VPNs.

Radio is difficult if not impossible to block with clever operators. The system is known.

Satellite will always be subject to whoever is in power at the time and it won't work within a building.

If you want to get information in and out the best option is—and possible always will be–a network of skilled radio operators.

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#174

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“Hey, Turkish ISPs? This is the government. We’re gonna need you to black hole some BGP routes or else. Thanks.”

I’m sure this would be happening in any country. Even USA. I’m not defending Turkey here though.

I just meant that unless customers were talking to satellites directly, presumably there would still be a Turkish ISP in the middle that would be able to route Facebook et al into the æther. But maybe I’m misunderstanding how Starlink works.

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#175

Echoing another comment: does anyone here know how this block is implemented? Is it a DNS block?

Turkey used to implement DNS blocks but these days (because people learned to quickly circumvent DNS blocks by Google or OpenDNS) they straight up don't route the IPs.

They still do implement DNS blocks for less commonly visited websites. Turkey does blocking at multiple layers ranging from street terminators to central gateways.

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#176
i live in istanbul/turkey, and i read most of the comments. the solutions provided ( dns, telegram, other mediums to use etc... ) seems practical but you are missing one thing, that part of the turkey, just started to use tools like twittter, fb, etc.. they don't have same knowledge as we in istanbul.

Blocking twitter, fb, and other tools, was their only chance to get information. i don't say all the information on those platforms are %100 correct but still, they are better then government provided.

Also imagine that, people on that area are just close to the border, yesterday two bombs dropped and 9 people died, 48 people injured and that is just the beginning. there was only social media for them to speak out now they don't. I don't usually follow the press but just because this is a fckng war, i read some news and articles. I can say that, if those people don't distribute the news or stuff happening there, I'm pretty sure the world will not know what is going on there and they will continue to create their own stories.

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#177
post #51

I'm still shocked at how thoroughly the United States betrayed the groups like YPG that we were working with months ago. Destroying fortifications on the Syrian border [1], providing intel to Turkey. There's an official denial of a "green light", but it's pretty clear that that's exactly what it was -- a surprise withdrawal and support ahead of Turkey's offensive. U.S. hardware, support, and consent. It might as well…

> [1] https://twitter.com/sojtfoir/status/1175869891305451522

> [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/09/world/middleeast/turkey-a.... ("Because of an American counterterrorism partnership with Turkey, Turkish aircraft were given access to a suite of American battlefield intelligence in northeast Syria.")

That is related to this: https://twitter.com/hashtag/securitymechanism?src=hashtag_cl...

The agreement was supposed to protect the Kurdish groups from a Turkish offensive by de-escalating the areas that the US had deemed "safe", while providing an umbrella of US control.

Trump then disgustingly yanked the umbrella away and let the Turks have at it.

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We don't know the facts. This absolutely might be leading to genocide. The fact that they are cutting social media is even more evidence it might go in that direction.

You referring BBC as a safe source. I offer you to watch this whole video. You may see how prejudiced BBC is. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QdRIr0QFOqk

I see a pro-Turkey bias. They let a guy go on there from the Turkish government and push his propaganda, mostly unchecked. They didn't have anyone from the YPG giving their side.

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#179
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems like a fair threat to me. Turkey has been bearing the burden of accommodating the majority of Syrian refugees. If Europe blocks its efforts to stabilize a part of Syria so it can repatriate Syrians, it seems logical to tell Europe "if you won't support our solution, you should share the cost of accommodating the refugees".

> Turkey has been bearing the burden of accommodating the majority of Syrian refugees. Are you aware that this is wholly down to a deal between the EU and Turkey which includes, amongst others, payments of about 6bn EUR to Turkey?

Turkey has spent more than $30 billion on refugees and was already host to 2 million refugees in 2015 (i.e. before the deal) [1]. So, no, that deal hasn't brought any meaningful change.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2019/jun/19/gaziantep-tur...

Re: Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram Restricted in Southern Turkey

#180
post #61
post #51

I'm still shocked at how thoroughly the United States betrayed the groups like YPG that we were working with months ago. Destroying fortifications on the Syrian border [1], providing intel to Turkey. There's an official denial of a "green light", but it's pretty clear that that's exactly what it was -- a surprise withdrawal and support ahead of Turkey's offensive. U.S. hardware, support, and consent. It might as well…

I'm more shocked at comments like yours that get echoed and promoted without any context whatsoever, but then again "Anti-Turkishism" is a thing. What I'm shocked about is how a so called ally can side and arm a vowed terrorist group for years and expect there to be no fallout, but then "Pro-Kurdishism" is a thing. I do love however the narrative that the Kurds are this angelic force that helped us when no other woul…

Opposition to Erdogan's apparent desire to murder all those who oppose him =/= opposition to Turkey.
Post reply on HN