Live data from Hacker News

Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 36 posts

Re: Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

#21
post #8

noooo... this is what you see on mobile: https://i.redd.it/ao5outqo0es21.png Please use Blogger! if anything, for historic reasons

That is almost hilarious would it not be for real. Out of curiosity may I ask what device you are using?

That's not even my device, its one of many screenshots from google. I would have to add to that the GDPR prompt , and most likely "you have exceeded your monthly limit or whatever". And those damn huge page headers don't ever go away

Re: Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

#22

I despised Medium from the start and saw it as a content farm. I have always had a policy of downvoting or flagging Medium articles on sight. If you have something to say, say it on your own website. Stop being a digital sharecropper.

Plenty of people don’t have the time or technical skills to make their own website. It’s also a good idea if someone wants to post a one off essay and/or post something anonymously and still reach people.

Re: Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

#24
I had the displeasure of being inexplicably banned from medium after posting a relatively high impact story, and it's absolutely the worst possible experience. Broken links all over social media, messed up SEO for a few weeks and so forth. Completely killed the story.

Re: Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

#25

I despised Medium from the start and saw it as a content farm. I have always had a policy of downvoting or flagging Medium articles on sight. If you have something to say, say it on your own website. Stop being a digital sharecropper.

Plenty of people don’t have the time or technical skills to make their own website. It’s also a good idea if someone wants to post a one off essay and/or post something anonymously and still reach people.

They could use Neocities.

Re: Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

#26

If you benefit from users visiting your website, then post it there. Quality content on a domain name you own will benefit your site’s overall SEO (expertise, authority, trust). Then tweet it and share it on LinkedIn. Posting it on medium would be like giving them all those benefits, while getting a very short burst of visibility. If you absolutely must post on medium, then post only a summary of your main blog. Then…

Doesn’t medium allow you to set the canonical URL? You can post on your blog first and then on medium with the canonical URL set to your blog.

Re: Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

#29
I've done Facebook blogging very effectively for the last 5 years. Nearly all the jobs I got in that period were from people who followed my Facebook, and I even landed a management tier job.

But after some experiments, I realized that people were only reading the first 10 words and then agreeing or disagreeing based on comments. So it's not possible to do high impact things in that format.

The other downside is that it Facebook, LinkedIn, HN, etc, they force you to fit their format. You can't post a full blown 5000 word article because nobody will read it. It has to be refined in a way, which is good, but not everything can be simplified, and complex ideas just don't work.

Medium, as well as places like DEV, are full of people who write to promoting themselves as experts or marketing a service. They're focused on either making everything look like a nail or making small problems seem more complex than it is. There's very little actual interesting content or deep thoughts on complex situations, and/or the algorithm does not show them. It's also really hard to identify the bad content at a glance; you'd have to read stuff for 3 minutes to discover the author has no idea what they're talking about.

So Medium and DEV, while technically decent, are so filled with junk that anything on there is associated with junk.

Re: Is Medium still the place to publish high-impact articles?

#30

May I take this opportunity to recommend Epiphany, a new blogging experience tailored for tech content? https://epiphany.pub/post?refId=2684bc94f9fcb9ffe637ebfbeba2... Epiphany is a crossover of Jupyter notebook and Medium.com, Not only can you write text, you can also program on it, to create interactive examples, see: https://epiphany.pub/post?refId=4c411b8a0b5207739f97e787d2af... In addition to interactivity, Epip…

What's the catch? I can't find a pricing page. This looks like something that could be potentially more expensive than Ghost.
Post reply on HN