Live data from Hacker News

Dyson has scrapped its electric car project

bbc.com

21–30 of 258 posts

Re: Dyson has scrapped its electric car project

#23
I'm surprised at this - seems bizarre that it's a 'great product' but isn't commercially viable in any way?

As an aside, I really can't understand why people are so enthusiastic about Dyson products - I find them to be poor to use and poor performers. My gf has a dyson vacuum cleaner (a v6, I think), and it's terrible. Battery life is minimal, the suction is poor compared to anything I've used in the past, all the novelty parts of it (motorised roller, etc) turned to filthy junk pretty quickly, and it trashes the bearings for the carpet roller with monotonous regularity as it can't deal with hair (household with three females with long hair). Emptying it can only be described as like giving a Wookee a prostate examination - it's a revolting process that makes mess everywhere and means I have to scrub my hands afterwards (it doesn't empty like it does in the advert if you have any hair present in there, which there always is in my case).

I had a V1 dyson back in the day, and it was useless as you couldn't get under any furniture. Dyson hand dryers in public toilets don't dry your hands in the claimed 10 seconds, they take about the same time as any other dryer, and usually lead to wet washroom floors as they blow the water all over the place.

I just don't get it - is it form over function and people go mad for them, but clearly I'm missing something. I know he employs incredibly clever people, and no doubt things have been engineered within an inch of their lives, but it always seems they're optomising variables that I don't care about.

Re: Dyson has scrapped its electric car project

#25
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please elaborate

He was very pro-Brexit, then left the country and moved to Singapore.

Unclear how that makes him a terrible human being.

Obama was against school choice, but he and all his children went to private schools.

Does that hypocrisy make Obama a terrible human being?

Re: Dyson has scrapped its electric car project

#27

I'm pretty surprised to find that Dyson even had an electric car project. The business similarity between vacuums and vehicles seems pretty low to me. Is it just the electric motors and Li-ion batteries?

In Dyson's case they also have a fair amount of consumer focused industrial design and marketing chops and brand recognition.

But yes, batteries and motors get you a long way toward producing an electric car. At first approximation, EVs are batteries, motors, and motor speed control systems, essentially huge equivalents of electric RC cars that many played with as children.

I suspect that VW's big push into mass market electric vehicles (the ID3) probably made them reconsider, especially given VW's production scale in the mass market segment. Consider the heroics Tesla has had to undertake to ramp to the scale they are at. My guess is that they are the last "new" car maker who will make it through the finish line.

Re: Dyson has scrapped its electric car project

#28

I'm pretty surprised to find that Dyson even had an electric car project. The business similarity between vacuums and vehicles seems pretty low to me. Is it just the electric motors and Li-ion batteries?

From their pre-cancellation PR, that seems to have been exactly the bet, that their existing expertise in electric motors and batteries would carry over as a competitive advantage.

I mean, that feels like saying because I can cook dinner for myself I should create a food distribution company.

Re: Dyson has scrapped its electric car project

#29
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please elaborate

He was very pro-Brexit, then left the country and moved to Singapore.

Dyson moved it's HQ to Singapore with the CEO stating: “We have seen an acceleration of opportunities to grow the company from a revenue perspective in Asia"

I don't see why this makes Dyson a terrible person.

Re: Dyson has scrapped its electric car project

#30
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please elaborate

He was very pro-Brexit, then left the country and moved to Singapore.

Well, his move to Singapore apparently was to address the lack of finding engineering talent in the UK which has been a chronic issue in the UK for a long time.

Simply finding talent elsewhere doesn't make Dyson a 'bad person' and this move has nothing got to do with the EU or Brexit in general.

Post reply on HN