Live data from Hacker News

South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

twitter.com

51–60 of 248 posts

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#51
post #19

Such a good episode. South Park seems to get better with each season.

I don't know if I'd go that far. I'd argue South Park was at its peak for the first 10 seasons. This episode was awesome but there has been quite a bit of junk between now and then. Obviously just my opinion though.

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their portrayal of Scientology got Chef to quit. And the chickenshits at Comedy Central will never again air the episodes featuring Mohammed. But otherwise I don't think anyone cares all that much.

So it's like NBA, where you encourage suboptimal coulored men to speak up and then back off because winnie the pooh got hurt? how many americans do watch SP, you reckon?

Im thinking this is a non native language issue and no harm was intended but the wording of "sub optimal coloured men" would probably be interpreted as offensive by some and actually just doesn't totally make sense.

Maybe "marginalized" may be closer to the word you were looking for?

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#54
post #49

Is it fair to assume that this is all of comedy Central giving China the finger as well as just the south park team? I would imagine China would take this up to the producers? And I imagine Comedy Central is directly involved in the production/funding? If so that's a pretty awesome and hold move on their part. I could see this leading to other shows feeling compelled to choose a side as well. I hope it does.

On the other hand, it's also easy to give them the finger when you don't have billions at stake.

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#56
post #34

Please explain like I'm five. What's the social status of SP in the USA? E.g. what do Chomsky, Obama, Trump, Chelsea Clinton, Fox news think about it? How come there are no rage firings because of it?

People are used to it and don't care about it anymore.

South Park was pretty nice to Obama overall and he had a decent ability to take a joke so I'm guessing he liked it.

I assure you Trump does not like South Park.

But at the end of the day it doesn't matter what they think. There would be huge outrage if a President tried to silence a satirical show. They wouldn't be able to get away with it.

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#57
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So it's like NBA, where you encourage suboptimal coulored men to speak up and then back off because winnie the pooh got hurt? how many americans do watch SP, you reckon?

Im thinking this is a non native language issue and no harm was intended but the wording of "sub optimal coloured men" would probably be interpreted as offensive by some and actually just doesn't totally make sense. Maybe "marginalized" may be closer to the word you were looking for?

No, it was sarcastic. i was referring to an anchorwoman, that suggested LeBron "should shut up and dribble". But obviously I'm not a native speaker

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#58
post #51
post #19

Such a good episode. South Park seems to get better with each season.

I don't know if I'd go that far. I'd argue South Park was at its peak for the first 10 seasons. This episode was awesome but there has been quite a bit of junk between now and then. Obviously just my opinion though.

Thr 2016 elections season was so darn good. Thats just my opinion as well. It became my favorite. I was never watching South Park like others did as it airs. I think shows like South Park you should have breaks on and then watch an episode or two on Hulu cause over time it does get tiresome. I can binge Family Guy and South Park but a lot gets lost compared to savoring it over time. Watched a lot of classic movies thanks to obscure Family Guy references.

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#59

i wonder if China has copied SP and if so how they would portray the USA. Has anything been made like this? And is it just as funny?

Hardliners can't be funny. That's why there's no 'woke' humor either.

Agreed. Humor can’t take itself too seriously, and its best targets are people or organizations that do.

Humor with an agenda doesn’t work.

Re: South Park Responds to Being Banned in China for “Band in China”

#60

Please explain like I'm five. What's the social status of SP in the USA? E.g. what do Chomsky, Obama, Trump, Chelsea Clinton, Fox news think about it? How come there are no rage firings because of it?

South Park has been around for so long, and has gone after so many things, its probable they've tackled several issues in a way that really resonates with you, and makes you laugh at the same time. And in many cases, they've paid a cost that others would be unwilling to bear in doing so.

This China thing is a current example. The NBA is cravenly grovelling to the CPC, and the SP creators are taking a proverbial dump on the lawns of the CPC and the NBA and Hollywood self-censors, while giving zero-fucks. Its great. Its inspiring. Another was when Isaac Hayes (actor who voiced Chef, and a Scientologist) quit when they did their Scientology episode (and it was such a brilliant episode, and at a time when Scientology was a bit of a sacred cow in Hollywood). Isaac had no problem when SP went (and continues to go) after Christianity.

Chances are, even if they really piss you off at some point, there have been other times when they've made you cheer and laugh.

Post reply on HN