Live data from Hacker News

The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

medium.com

31–40 of 47 posts

Re: The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

#31
post #26
post #21

I sold my mobile maps startup to Google around the same time and worked closely with the where2 guys. This article sounds like the result of a casual conversation with Noel and not a well researched piece. A number of inaccuracies as far as I can remember. (not blaming Noel to be clear)

> A number of inaccuracies as far as I can remember. Do you mind clarify these?

Two clear inaccuracies are that the team worked out of the mountain view office and they joined months before the ipo.

Re: The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

#34

Typical medium article. Scant and clickbaity (fell for it this time). Is there a way to block all medium articles from my feed?

I am sure you’ll find an article on medium about that. Probable title: “7 great ways to block all medium articles from your feed”

Sorry for the irony... I hate medium too :)

Re: The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

#35
post #2

I was hoping for a little more detail around the beginnings of AJAX. I know it was added to IE to support Outlook in IE but I thought Maps was the first big use of it outside of Outlook.

Nah, the idea of realtime communication between browser and server is as old as javascript. I implemented my first version in 1997, using hidden iframes loading scripts, but I don't imagine I was the first to do so. Relevant to the article, I actually also implemented a draggable map that loaded tiles dynamically on demand for a little failed outdoor startup in 1998. The limiting factor back then was actually the ser…

> The limiting factor back then was actually the server.

Do you still feel confident that the server was an unsolvable limit? Like, the expectations for map resolution were not all that lofty in 1997, and it's still today pretty common to precompute tiles at different ranges/scales.

Re: The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

#37

This story is told really well in one of my favorite podcasts, the Acquired Podcast: https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/google-maps . Highly recommended as are all of the other episodes.

The two co-hosts' valleyspeak inflections became intolerable. I'm sure their story was more complete than the medium article, but it was like Guy Raz times two.

Re: The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

#38
post #2

I was hoping for a little more detail around the beginnings of AJAX. I know it was added to IE to support Outlook in IE but I thought Maps was the first big use of it outside of Outlook.

Whenever people talk about how IE ruined the internet, I think about AJAX. I actually thought IE was great for the web. A poignant example I remember was, if you got a /TR /TD out of order, Netscape wouldn't show the web page at all. It'd work fine in IE though. IE just made it so much easier to move fast in web development. People blast IE, but I really don't think the web would be as good as it is today without it.…

Also css, early on.

Anybody remember LAYER tags?

Re: The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

AJAX's origins are actually really cool. It started before XmlHttpRequest. If I recall correctly, when the user took an action that required a server response, the javascript would make a 1px by 1px iframe and load it to a specific URL with the important information in the query parameters. The response would look something like this someGlobalFunction({ searchResults: [ {"name": "Joseph Paul"}, {"name": "Joe McCray"…

A lot of early web apps heavily abused this pattern - I worked on a web framework that used iframes to manage widget state, and of course at that time everyone had to support IE5 and 6. But those browsers by default had this charming noise (an audible click) every time a page loaded or iframe loaded. When you would click a widget button you’d here this curious storm of clicks as the iframes all reloaded. That culmina…

But those browsers by default had this charming noise (an audible click) every time a page loaded or iframe loaded. When you would click a widget button you’d here this curious storm of clicks as the iframes all reloaded.

Wow. I'd forgotten about that. And all these years later, now I know what was going on.

Re: The Founding of Google Maps (2015)

#40
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nah, the idea of realtime communication between browser and server is as old as javascript. I implemented my first version in 1997, using hidden iframes loading scripts, but I don't imagine I was the first to do so. Relevant to the article, I actually also implemented a draggable map that loaded tiles dynamically on demand for a little failed outdoor startup in 1998. The limiting factor back then was actually the ser…

> The limiting factor back then was actually the server. Do you still feel confident that the server was an unsolvable limit? Like, the expectations for map resolution were not all that lofty in 1997, and it's still today pretty common to precompute tiles at different ranges/scales.

Sounds like a capacity issue. How many tiles can you store on a hard drive with a maximum capacity of about 6GB? Especially at 1997 prices.
Post reply on HN