Live data from Hacker News

W3C HTML5 Logo Unveiled

w3.org

31–40 of 111 posts

Re: W3C HTML5 Logo Unveiled

#31
I have to say that I find the icons to be really, really ridiculous.

It doesn't look like something someone hired from outside did, and the HTML5 logo looks like the header on a Tutsplus vector tutorial.

Most of the different icons have very poor symbolic value, and look really unintelligible.

They could do a lot worse, so that's always something.

Re: W3C HTML5 Logo Unveiled

#33
post #24

I'm not certain I like it. Think about its purpose; it needs to work with a huge range of styles, each of which will have specific and varied audiences. The choices made (collegiate typeface / bright orange) are quite bold; I don't think it lends itself to sympathetically supporting a broad range of differing styles of design. Also, when this is used, it's likely to be quite small - the gap between the tail of the '5…

Also, when this is used, it's likely to be quite small - the gap between the tail of the '5' and its upper curve is slight. I think it will have a tendency to resemble a '6' at smaller resolutions. Someone realized this. If you look at the favicon, they've dropped the tail.

Ah, well, I think that impacts on consistency.

The smaller version of the logo should be the primary use-case imo.

Re: W3C HTML5 Logo Unveiled

#34

It's super strange that this page itself is HTML5. Doesn't W3C have a policy of only publishing documents using standards already in the "Recommendation" stage?

What irks me more is that they made another one of those one-page scroll-till-your-eyes-bleed sites to show the logo off. I don't know where this new "trend" is coming from, but I find it really tiresome already.

Re: W3C HTML5 Logo Unveiled

#35
post #4
post #3

I don't know why, but it puts a smile on my face. I guess, the logo shows some confidence previously unassociated with boring standard bodies.

Maybe it reminds you of Moses from South Park? http://www.google.co.uk/images?q=moses+south+park

No way... the new HTML5 logo reminds me of a 2d paper cutout version of the Master Control Program.

Re: W3C HTML5 Logo Unveiled

#36
I really like it. It looks acceptably corporate, but it has a hint of the whole 'unicorns are awesome!' early-adopter-webdev aesthetic that will put a smile on the face of the people who actually use html5 day to day, and evangelise for it.

Sort of like dog whistle politics but used for good :)

Re: W3C HTML5 Logo Unveiled

#38
post #7

Is that how HTMTL5 websites are supposed to look like? With the cluttered layout, the various fonts and sizes, the flashy colours and the interactive content I find this page incredibly difficult to parse. It's hard for me to extract the important informations from the text. Is it really about the new logo? What's the deal with the "HTML5 semantics" on the middle? I know nothing of web development, so I have no idea…

You forgot to mention a future filled with unblockable canvas advertisements filling up 70-80% of the content on every page, eating up huge swaths of CPU time.
Post reply on HN