Live data from Hacker News

I got a bad review from TechCrunch, lessons learned

joshliu.co

41–47 of 47 posts

Re: I got a bad review from TechCrunch, lessons learned

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe new to to you, but X came out in 2009.

nono, X verifies start-ups who are using them. We cannot use them without their approval. We have submitted the application. Once we get that from them, we can then make our site live.

You are relying a great deal on paypal approving you. I hope you have a backup plan.

Re: I got a bad review from TechCrunch, lessons learned

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

nono, X verifies start-ups who are using them. We cannot use them without their approval. We have submitted the application. Once we get that from them, we can then make our site live.

You are relying a great deal on paypal approving you. I hope you have a backup plan.

Their Pre-authorised payment and parallel payment fit our model perfectly. Our CTO knows them pretty well. We think it is the best option for our initial stage. Once we scale, we will look for more payment options.

Re: I got a bad review from TechCrunch, lessons learned

#43
post #35

I feel bad for the OP ... that was definitely a harsh review. That said, I notice that he called this a "Minimum Viable Product," which is a term of art from the Lean Startup methodology. That very same methodology says you're not supposed to have some big TechCrunch launch with that MVP ... precisely because it is almost certainly not ready for primetime. The point of the MVP is to get it in front of real customers,…

Totally agreed that it was one of my mistakes. It was wrong to get TC review so early. Another lesson learned. :)

Awesome writeup, by the way, thanks for posting this!

Re: I got a bad review from TechCrunch, lessons learned

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Another point Steve Blank talks about this in Stanford series of talks on customer development: http://ecorner.stanford.edu/authorMaterialInfo.html?mid=2060 [video] He mentions any type of PR, Press including TechCrunch coverage shouldn't be sought after before contact with the customers and is part of a strategy and not a random tactic. And this is typically after you figure out what business you are in, who your cu…

Absolutely, good point. It's hard to resist the urge, though - seeking coverage (to get confirmation or otherwise) is only natural when you are passionate about your start up and want to tell the world what you are doing. Customer development is still massively undervalued, though.

Customer development is very much like the screening of a unreleased movie. A studio will get a nearly finished product in front of movie-goers before releasing it using that feedback to tighten plot points, editing, etc. The difference with a web-based product and a movie is that continually feedback loop never ends for the web-based product.

Re: I got a bad review from TechCrunch, lessons learned

#47
post #40
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's a TC Europe? (I'm from Europe and I didn't notice.)

It looks more like UK TC and there's even a France TC ! I think nobody know about them. [edit] Well not only UK, first page just happened to be very UK oriented but if you read further there is a bit more diversity.

Hmm, it's sad. We need a stronger start-up/tech entrepreneur scene in Europe. Everything is so valley centric :(
Post reply on HN