Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

ieddit.com

81–90 of 171 posts

Re: Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

#81
post #12

Have you thought about making the data distributed and p2p? that way it's more resilient. Reddit at one stage was also minimalist and open source

Consider Member -

https://memberapp.github.io/

It's got Reddit style functionality (HN style theme at present) with all content on the Bitcoin (BCH) blockchain.

Re: Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

#82

How will you avoid- > John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory was proposed in the Penny Arcade (web comic) on March 19, 2004 by Mike Krahulik and Jerry Holkins. It says that when a normal person is allowed anonymity and an audience, they lose social inhibitions and act inappropriately. If anything, the last decade has taught us the immutability of this law. Usernames and comment history seem to help somewhat w…

Register user but don't show any identifiers when they post. They can speak freely as the user can be anonymous but their data is still stored somewhere so they can't act without any thoughts.

Re: Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

#83
post #61

How will you avoid- > John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory was proposed in the Penny Arcade (web comic) on March 19, 2004 by Mike Krahulik and Jerry Holkins. It says that when a normal person is allowed anonymity and an audience, they lose social inhibitions and act inappropriately. If anything, the last decade has taught us the immutability of this law. Usernames and comment history seem to help somewhat w…

Internet fuckwads are fine as long as they stay limited to their own communities. What you and I deem a 'fuckwad' will vary greatly. While somebody spamming 'hitler did nothing wrong' is certainly a fuckwad, it is only an issue which this fuckwadry is exposed to those who were not expressively looking for it. I see zero issues in fuckwads congregating if they stick to themselves.

The issue is they never do.

Re: Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

#84

I like the idea of having a website like reddit, similar functionality without the bloat. The new reddit design is horrible. The design on the site could be a little closer to this site perhaps.

https://old.reddit.com/

This is how I still browse the site. You can also disable subreddit theming in your preferences and you’ve got a much more lite version of the site like the old days.

Re: Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

#86

How will you avoid- > John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory was proposed in the Penny Arcade (web comic) on March 19, 2004 by Mike Krahulik and Jerry Holkins. It says that when a normal person is allowed anonymity and an audience, they lose social inhibitions and act inappropriately. If anything, the last decade has taught us the immutability of this law. Usernames and comment history seem to help somewhat w…

Be careful if you're at work. There's already porn on this thing in some of the Imgur links. I miss the late 90s when you had a lot of small, independent websites. Sure there was always a war against spammers and scripts, but I feel like you could find more independent content from individuals instead of these big link aggregation platforms (remember web-rings?) There is more to think about today when making somethin…

Lobsters is invite only (last I checked) so that prevents spam.

Re: Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

#87

How will you avoid- > John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory was proposed in the Penny Arcade (web comic) on March 19, 2004 by Mike Krahulik and Jerry Holkins. It says that when a normal person is allowed anonymity and an audience, they lose social inhibitions and act inappropriately. If anything, the last decade has taught us the immutability of this law. Usernames and comment history seem to help somewhat w…

Be careful if you're at work. There's already porn on this thing in some of the Imgur links. I miss the late 90s when you had a lot of small, independent websites. Sure there was always a war against spammers and scripts, but I feel like you could find more independent content from individuals instead of these big link aggregation platforms (remember web-rings?) There is more to think about today when making somethin…

Most Masto/Pleroma instances are too small to be worth the trouble. I get about 1-2 spam bots signing up per week, usually deleted automatically or within 1 hour of signing up (longer if all the admins are sleeping).

Small instances that don't do anything about spam usually get defederated fairly quickly.

With the way federation works, your reach is very unpredictable and you need to attach to very large instances if you want to have any effect. And large instances have more moderators to more quickly handle them.

Per-user mastodon probably has more moderators/administrators than comparable services (twitter), so it's a bit more clean.

Re: Show HN: Ieddit – A minimalist, Reddit-like site with anonymous posts/comments

#90

How will you avoid- > John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory was proposed in the Penny Arcade (web comic) on March 19, 2004 by Mike Krahulik and Jerry Holkins. It says that when a normal person is allowed anonymity and an audience, they lose social inhibitions and act inappropriately. If anything, the last decade has taught us the immutability of this law. Usernames and comment history seem to help somewhat w…

> If anything, the last decade has taught us the immutability of this law. Or equally likely-- there are a tiny fraction of bona fide users who act moderately anti-social on the net when granted anonymity, just as they would in real life. It's just that forums with no little to no publishing friction allow those people to do 100x damage compared to what they could get away with in real life. Add to that: * corporate-…

I don’t know, there seem to be various levels of anonymity with different social implications. Let’s roughly differenciate between:

1. Full Anonymity (no way to differenciate between user A and B except by the content)

2. Anonymous Pseudonymity (Users can take usernames, but they don’t mean a lot because they can be changed fast and there is no per user post history)

3. Accountbuilding Pseudonymity (Users usually stick to their accounts, Per user post history or karma is visible and meaningful)

4. Mandatory Real Names (on top of the stuff in point 3 you also have to use your real name - but face no consequences if you make something up)

5. Enforced Real Names (same as point 4, but the service provider has to check your identity)

Positive effects of mandatory real name policies could never been proven — as far as I know they haven’t improved civility e.g. on facebook.

I believe the secret lies more in the feedback systems and how easy it is to flip or flop your position away from what you historically said. It helps if all community interactions or rules are clear and minimalistic instead of arbitrary and arcane.

All of this together weakens or strengthens the impact of the kind of user you mentioned. So in short: the emergent culture on really bad image boards is also part of their systemic design, just like it is with hn, facebook, instagram and any other online plattform. I think the type mentioned in point 3 (accountbuilding) paired with clever measures to keep the aims of the community aligned help a lot.

Post reply on HN