Live data from Hacker News

Inside Bill’s Brain

netflix.com

91–100 of 101 posts

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Many of the things that he is doing also have huge political implications. From the U.S. that isn't obvious. Some wealthy guy can dole out cash but the system is stable, so that is fine. Outside of the U.S. the opposite is true. Wealthy guy comes in and starts handing out cash, and that occurs within a political context (which is often the issue: these places often don't lack money or tech, what they lack is stable p…

There are big implications inside the US too. Gates favors large-scale privatization of American public schools and de-professionalization of schoolteachers, and his “philanthropy” is actively harmful to US students. Public policy should be decided by the public, not by the whims of unaccountable billionaires, however pure their intentions might be.

But the point is that if you do that within the U.S. that occurs within a stable policy context.

I accept the idea that this spending feels uncontrolled. Education policy is one area where you see this kind of activity because power is often local and fragmented which makes it easier to control. But there is still a relatively stable context with good oversight.

Imagine that occurring but there is no oversight: no teacher unions, no state govts, no opposition govt, no media, no oversight or reporting of meetings with NGOs, no reporting of donations, and (potentially) some level of govt that is captive.

And it doesn't need to be about Gates aiming to influence public policy directly. But actions that seem neutral, building a school or providing vaccinations, often occur in a political context (Mugabe was notorious for controlling the provision of aid around elections).

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Though he has pledged to give away his fortune. So far he has given out $35billion. On things like curing malaria, as opposed to buying self-portraits and NFL memorabilia. I’d say his behavior is the text book definition of great.

He hasn't given away anything he's still the one spending it.

I believe ‘spending money on a grant’ is ‘giving away money’.

The foundation distributed $4bn through grants in 2018. See https://www.gatesfoundation.org/Who-We-Are/General-Informati...

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#93
I would have liked more on his current ventures and the logistics behind them but it would not make for a Netflix Documentary I guess. Still entertaining.

For the logistics and the problems with toilets, "World's Toilet Crisis" by Vanguard is good, they don't shy away from the issue at hand, talking about open defecation and solutions.

Things like children who open defecate on water often do it at night, for the privacy, and can drown, although diarrhoea is the not talked about real killer but it gets less clicks https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2017/feb/15/s...

You'd notice the toilets deployed and talked about in the doco aren't very good, The Gates foundation did do some good work not shown but I guess it's not for a Netflix doco, it's more about the flashy stuff.

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#94
I just binge watched this. It was a really nice documentary.

Some of the things I didn't know about Bill Gates -

1. He loves diet coke! At one time he opens a refrigerator and it's only stacked with diet coke cans.

2. He reads a crazy amount of books. And he reads them, takes notes and is able to retain all that information. I found that remarkable.

3. He works hard. Really hard. And he takes on problems which seem insurmountable. Whether it's polio eradication, clean water, or nuclear reactors. And he approaches the problems from a technical point of view.

Some of the lines which I liked -

Director: I looked into the most prevalent criticisms of you, and this one actually seems the most relevant. "He's a technophile that thinks that technology will solve everything."

Bill: Yeah, I'm basically guilty of that. Any problem... I will look at how technical innovation can help solve that problem. It's the one thing I know and the one thing I'm good at. And so, you know, that's my hammer. And so lots of problems look like nails because I've got a hammer.

Director: Is there a part where you say, "This is way too hard, I took on too much, I quit".

Bill: Sometimes, you really do have to say, "Let's give up". And sometimes, you have to just say, "I need to work harder"

Mary Gates (Bill's mother): "Each one of us has to start out with developing his or her own definition of success. And when we have these specific expectations of ourselves, we're more like to live up to them. Ultimately, it's not what you get or even what you give. It's what you become."

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's supposed to be an honest raw look at his life. And frankly, it makes a lot of sense that he had poor work life balance. It's to be expected that extraordinary effort is required to build extraordinary things.

They could’ve told it honestly without making it seem like sleep deprivation is noble. Great things can be achieved with proper sleep and not falling asleep at your keyboard just to wake up and keep coding “right where you left off” as they claim.

Thats rarely true. No extraordinary thing was made with a 9 to 5 and then zone out.

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#96
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can’t do anything to please you people, even spending 35 billion a year on charity wouldn’t suffice.

Donate the money to someone completely independent, and stop talking about it.

don't sell yourself short, I'm sure you could find an issue with it even if he did that.

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#97
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not about disagreeing with his goals, it's about stylizing him as a Boogeyman using anti-Semitic tropes for political gains. The people who call Soros their enemy are literally fighting against liberal democracy. Orban himself states as his goal a illiberal democracy. You can disagree with Soros views on immigration, but there is no way in hell you can defend what has been done to him. What Soros advocates is a…

> The people who call Soros their enemy are literally fighting against liberal democracy. I haven't kept up with all the things Soros has been accused of (falsely or not), but isn't this statement also making them into boogeymen? They can't possibly be just against a handful of policies he's pushing in their country - they must be against liberal democracy itself? Why are the only two choices Soros, or enemies of lib…

Well, let's try: shoe me one valid point of critisim against Soros promoted ideas that is not illiberal.

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Rather than make abstract accusations that are theoretical, perhaps you could be specific. Gates has donated a lot to basic health, vaccination, malaria, clean water. Saying that some of it might be siphoned away by corrupt locals doesn’t remove any good done. The same is true of internationally run NGOs, the WHO, UN, USAID, etc the locals get some power and capital siphoned from the system. But there is no system th…

That is the issue. You are making assumptions about what you think Gates is like. Gates is nice. He is like me. That isn't how it should work (because most impressions about people are wrong, and heavily influenced by things like Netflix documentaries). And the point is: all the other bodies you mention have controls over how they spend. There is direct oversight of their spending, and yes some money goes missing...b…

I'm only judging by results and facts. You're talking in vague terms and not citing any facts. Did you even bother to look at the biggest recipients of Gates Foundation donations? A lot of the money he's donated has gone to the World Health Organization, which is exactly the policy makers and deliberative body you're asking him to go through. A lot of Gates Foundation orgs are transparent, and the orgs they donate too are often international NGO or GOs like the WHO.

Gates Foundation Donations:

$2.6 billion to GAVI, global vaccine alliance

$2.2 billion to WHO

$1.3 billion to United Negro College Fund

$800 million to Unicef

$700 million to global AIDS and Malaria foundations

$500 million to John Hopkins University

$500 million to global tuberculosis org

I don't see any facts posted that quantify what the Gates Foundation is doing, how money is being distributed, or how many people have been helped. I've just posted some.

I mean good lord, the UN/WHO has some figures on this:

450 million mosquito nets given out due to Gates

Near eradication of Guinea worm thanks to Carter Center, whose major benefactor is Gates (3.5 million infections eliminated)

7.3 million people got anti-retroviral AIDS treatment thanks to Gates funding

12 million people got TB testing from Gates Foundation funding

500 million children vaccinated by GAVI

24 million women got access to family planning thanks to Gates

You're making all sorts of claims that Gates does not work with policy makers. Really? Bill Gates rolodex does not include the ability to dial up and talk to practically any diplomat or government official in the world? You don't think Gates Org talks with with international health officials or local governments and they're just going cowboy everywhere?

What's the evidence?

Some people voted down my comments, but none of them provided ANY information to back up claims that the Gates foundation is doing something wrong, that they haven't been effective. About the only claim with any weight at all is the dispute about the efficacy of charter schools, but that runs into an ideological debate about how the school system and teaching should work and there opinions widely differ. Far more damage to the educational system has been done by the existing policy makers.

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#99
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The people who call Soros their enemy are literally fighting against liberal democracy. I haven't kept up with all the things Soros has been accused of (falsely or not), but isn't this statement also making them into boogeymen? They can't possibly be just against a handful of policies he's pushing in their country - they must be against liberal democracy itself? Why are the only two choices Soros, or enemies of lib…

Well, let's try: shoe me one valid point of critisim against Soros promoted ideas that is not illiberal.

I'm not sure if it's liberal or not, but opposition to immigration seems perfectly legitimate to me, and is directly opposed to Soros' goals.

Re: Inside Bill’s Brain

#100
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not to mention his philanthropy work frequently causes considerable damage itself, like the malaria nets[0] that poisoned the local food supply, the failed public school overhaul[1] and common core[2][3]. [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/25/world/africa/mosquito-net... [1]: https://nancyebailey.com/2018/07/04/gatess-blunders-destroy-... [2]: https://www.philanthropydaily.com/gates-philanthropy-failure... [3]: htt…

Can’t do anything to please you people, even spending 35 billion a year on charity wouldn’t suffice.

So, you are saying nobody should scrutinize the charity?
Post reply on HN