Live data from Hacker News

Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

slate.com

31–40 of 174 posts

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#31
post #4

It seems that the reason it's wrong is that typographers say it is. The author has not given an actual reason , other than appeal to authority. I will continue to double-space until I'm dead.

  > I will continue to double-space until I'm dead.
Do you have a reason for doing so?

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#32
Using two spaces after the end of a sentence allows software to recognize sentences without doubt. There are no heuristics involved which would always be on the verge of failing. That allows me to issue commands which works on sentences mindlessly, and to enable auto-capitalization. The former is the killer feature.

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#34
Wikipedia has a much more comprehensive review of the issues: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentence_spacing

In general, modern typesetting software (and/or fonts) should be able to properly set the width of spaces between sentences to be slightly wider than than those between words. Unfortunately, TeX is the only common typesetter I know that does this.

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#35
Articles with the word "never" in the title: Beware their myopia, lack of vision, and narrow-mindedness.

Articles with the word "ever" in the title: Beware their gross generalizations, lack of gray area, and hasty conclusions.

Articles with both the words "never" and "ever" in the title: Never, ever read them. (oops)

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#36
If the MLA says one space then it has changed since I was in school (~10 years ago). We were always told to use a double space at the end of a sentence and while he links to the Chicago MLA, the actual MLA website also eludes to the fact that it used to be two spaces: http://www.mla.org/style_faq3.

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#37
post #31
post #4

It seems that the reason it's wrong is that typographers say it is. The author has not given an actual reason , other than appeal to authority. I will continue to double-space until I'm dead.

> I will continue to double-space until I'm dead. Do you have a reason for doing so?

Yes, because my typing teacher in 1975 told me to do it.

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#38
post #31
post #4

It seems that the reason it's wrong is that typographers say it is. The author has not given an actual reason , other than appeal to authority. I will continue to double-space until I'm dead.

> I will continue to double-space until I'm dead. Do you have a reason for doing so?

I do - deeply ingrained muscle memory from a touch typing class in high school, conditioned over years.

Re: Why you should never, ever use two spaces after a period

#39
post #2

He's amusingly wrong in his certainty that everybody else is wrong. Two spaces grew out of a typographic convention of using a 1.5-width space that was favored by typesetters for proportional typespaces because typewriters didn't have half-width spaces represented on their keyboards. The actually "correct" approach would be 1.5-character width spaces, because even in proportional typefaces a little extra space serves…

He's the least technical "technology columnist" I've ever read.

Being a supposed technology columnist, he should have been aware that yes, text is still often rendered in monospace fonts. His grasp of history is just horribly wrong: "Monospaced fonts went out in the 1970s. First electric typewriters and then computers began to offer people ways to create text using proportional fonts." He's talking about exotic hardware that was used by approximately no one.

Being a supposed technology columnist, he should also have done some research to find out how single and double spaces are rendered by word processors and email clients. Double-spacing is perfectly fine if word processors know what two spaces after a period mean and render it appropriately. I was taught that they do, so for me, double-spacing after a period seems like the perfect solution: double-spacing is the least bad solution for monospace fonts, and for proportional fonts, a double-space after a period will automatically be rendered correctly. If he wanted to do an actual service for his readers, he could have told us whether that is true or not. Since he is, you know, a technology columnist. Doesn't that title imply something beyond the ability to review smart phones?

Post reply on HN