Live data from Hacker News

Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

nytimes.com

191–200 of 238 posts

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#191
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you elaborate how you think that applies to this discussion? Seems like you are arguing semantics to me. The Church of Scientology is a considered a non-profit institution in the U.S. as well. Do you believe that The Church of Scientology is a benevolent actor? I don't. I believe their primary purpose is profit and they are taking advantage of their followers and the U.S. taxpayer in the same way these universiti…

You said the motivation was "profit" which means that the owners of the organization make money that they can go spend on themselves as they please. This literally does not happen for the vast majority of universities. What you are describing is more like "growth." And maybe the kinds of growth universities are investing in isn't great right now. That's a fine conversation to have. This isn't just a semantic distinct…

Growth is a much more direct proxy for power than pure cash.

Why would we allow someone to gain power without giving back to the society which provides safety nets for that power?

I am pretty certain Scientologists enjoy every bit of that money (be it expensive cars, free travel, more followers for your ego) they don’t pay in tax.

The same goes for universities: growth without purpose are only there to satisfy the egos of those who manage the money they never earned.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#192

It's not at all clear to me why we allow American football and universities to have such a perverse relationship, when it's plain to see that football itself has nothing to do with education, except insofar as it's an activity that many students enjoy (but there is no shortage of other non-academic activities that many students share, such as baseball...) And in cases like this, where students are leaving the game ea…

Once, on a hiring committee, someone said their definition of a "decent [American] college" was "You've heard of their football team".

I suspect that's a pretty prevalent opinion, wrong as it may be.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#193
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The way this whole thing started was between very urban Ivies in the USA: > The first organized college sports club was formed in 1843 when Yale University created a boat club.[4] Harvard University then followed in their footsteps, creating a similar boat club a year later. These boat clubs participated in rowing races called Regattas.[5] The creation of these organizations set the stage for the first intercollegiat…

I don’t disagree the sport started in the ivies, but not where it became massively commercialized. Right now the Northeastern football programs are not very competitive, with the exception of Notre Dame. I can’t do this analysis right now, but I’d bet that there is a strong correlation between college football revenue and distance from professional teams, adjusting for the date at which the professional teams were fo…

And Notre Dame is neither northeastern nor urban.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#194

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We let students major in theater, but not in football. There's a big difference.

> We let students major in theater, but not in football. Well, we usually don't call it “football” specifically, but “exercise science” or something similar is commonly available. And Baylor has “general studies”, which despite the generic name is intended to support “general career areas of health, fitness, recreation, and sport”, and that's what most of their football players major in.

I’ll also throw out that when I played (D3) football in college, the intellectual load of the sport was higher than in some of my academic classes. We’d spend an hour a day studying film, and on the field we were expected to know understand how our actions would effect multiple other parties in a system.

I still think I got more (intellectually) out of college level football than I did out of intro level sociology.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#195
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don’t disagree the sport started in the ivies, but not where it became massively commercialized. Right now the Northeastern football programs are not very competitive, with the exception of Notre Dame. I can’t do this analysis right now, but I’d bet that there is a strong correlation between college football revenue and distance from professional teams, adjusting for the date at which the professional teams were fo…

And Notre Dame is neither northeastern nor urban.

Segment the continental United States into quadrants. In which quadrant would the Notre Dame pin fall? It’s also about 1.5 hours from downtown Chicago. Tuscaloosa, Alabama is about 3.5 hours from the nearest major city with a sports team, Atlanta.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#196

Maybe the headline changed but the app is not penalizing students for leaving early but possibly rewarding them for staying. Crazy how headlines drive a narrative that often times does not match the reported facts. From an AP article on this... "if they stay in the stands at a home game at Bryant-Denny Stadium through the fourth quarter, students who have the app could be rewarded with highly coveted postseason ticke…

It's also opt-in. Sounds like fear mongering with clickbait. I don't see a problem with tracking I know about and can turn off at will. It's the tracking I don't know about and can't do anything about that's the issue.

"Students who download the Tide Loyalty Points app will be tracked only inside the stadium, he said, and they can close the app — or delete it — once they leave the stadium."

Jesus, I just realized it was the New York Times ...

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The likely reason they're using phones, not keycards, is because students would be more likely to let their buddy hold onto their keycard than their phone. A phone is more personal/sensitive and the stress of being without it for even a short period of time doubtlessly reduces the incidence rate of 'fraud.'

Doesn't everyone have an old phone at this point? Is the app going to check if activity implies it is their current phone? It seems easy and less intrusive for the majority(?) who wont get anything in return for installing a sketchy app to just give tickets out randomly toward the end of a game and anyone who is there at the end more often has a better chance of getting one.

Maybe, but this scheme still discourages casual spur-of-the-moment fraud.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#198
post #153

If we make college free, like some politicians are proposing, does football revenue even matter anymore?

It matters even more: making the service free to students doesn't make the inputs free to the college itself, and many plans for government funding include outcome-based accountability for government subsidies (that's even true for sone proposed reforms that don't make college free.), And no plan is going to let colleges charge whatever they want and get the government to pay he bill. One way to get better outcomes f…

Won’t the politicians just give even more money to the universities? Paint the chancellor’s office, get a check from the government. Cancel the football team, as it’s no longer politically correct, get even more funding.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#199
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tuition rates for Harvard and Princeton in particular are deceptive since if you earnestly cannot afford that tuition, they don't ask you to pay it. Those schools are often actually cheaper than public schools for people without much money. Other expensive private-nonprofit schools may be another matter entirely. But those two are bad examples to use.

> Those schools are often actually cheaper than public schools for people without much money. While this is true on paper, it's not always the case in practice. I was able to get multiple acceptance offers to Ivy League schools, and poor enough to have the sliding scale of tuition slide all the way to $0. But all of them had an estimated cost of attendance[1] so optimistic about ancillary expenses during the school y…

If you were accepted into multiple Ivies with full financial aid you were definitely eligible for work study and student loans.

Personally, I would recommend anyone in that situation to opt for the Ivy as it really does open doors later in life.

Re: Alabama tracking students' locations to penalize them for leaving games early

#200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have any evidence to back your assertion that team sport is necessary for childhood character development? How about your implied premise that team sport does a better job of improving physical health than individual sport or non-competive physical activity?

it's self evident if you ever been trough schooling, but since you want to play the evidence game let's start from a systemic study about team sport, socialization and psychological health https://ijbnpa.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1479-5868-...

If I thought the premise was self-evident, I would not have wasted my time challenging you. The review you cited covers effects of participation in team sport on physical well-being and certain markers of psychological well-being, but you claimed that sport builds character.

Perhaps I assumed a different meaning from the one you intended, but when I hear people going on about sport building character, they're usually talking about their idea of "moral character".

This study does not test, let alone support, the premise that sport builds moral character. Did you mean some other kind of character?

Post reply on HN