Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

lunchmoney.cc

11–20 of 135 posts

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#12
I was halfway through building something like this just for msyelf. My main issues with existing options are:

1. Mint and others always seem to automatically count transferring money from Chase to an external savings account as spending which drives me insane.

2. Not being able to split transactions (which you solved)

3. Reassign the date of a transaction, or from a technical perspective, create an "effective date" in addition to the true transaction date. I've been back and forth on whether this is actually a good idea or not. But I really want to count my July 5th electrical bill as a June expense, for example.

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#13
It looks pretty, but unfortunately I found budgeting methods that are not envelope based (such as YNAB where every dollar is assigned a job) are not adequate. After adopting the YNAB method I have seen how far superior it is.

If I could combine YNAB's budgeting method with your reporting & analysis we'd have a true winner.

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#14
post #8

Kudos. You've gone and done something a lot of us only plan to do but never get around to. I have a few questions though. 1. Does this work for everyone around the world? 2. How many ways do you have for sorting through transactions and making sense out of these? 3. My bank statements are a huge mess and I'd love a way I could aggregate all of my spend across multiple banks and cards. Sometimes, I send money to a fri…

Thank you so much!!

1. Right now I'm using Plaid to connect to bank accounts which currently only supports US and Canada-based banks (but even then, some banks are not supported fully). The next plan is to allow people to manually import their bank transactions via CSV, and after that, look into a European-based and/or Asia-based version of Plaid. That being said, anyone can use Lunch Money to add transactions manually in any of the 150+ currencies currently supported.

2. So we do a couple of things under the hood– auto-categorization and picking out your recurring (monthly) expenses. Our auto-categorization gets smarter as you make any fixes (via Category Rules). We also offer a lot of transaction management features such as splitting and grouping which you can use to make sense of your own spending habits.

3. Yes, our latest feature, grouped transactions, exactly fits your use case. You can use grouped transactions to link up credit card payments (i.e. -$200 from your chequing account, +200 to your credit card combines to $0 in your transactions list!) or track friends paying you back (i.e. you picked up the $200 tab for a dinner with 6 friends. You can group together that big transaction plus all your Venmo transactions to reflect how much your share actually was).

Thanks for the questions!

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#15
post #12

I was halfway through building something like this just for msyelf. My main issues with existing options are: 1. Mint and others always seem to automatically count transferring money from Chase to an external savings account as spending which drives me insane. 2. Not being able to split transactions (which you solved) 3. Reassign the date of a transaction, or from a technical perspective, create an "effective date" i…

Re: #3 In my own software, I always enter the initial date (or date I expect it to post) and then I don't worry TOO much about it unless say it's right at the end of the month. Because when I view reports, I want the month-end balance to match my real accounts. (For this reason, I also tend to avoid doing things like paying credit cards on the last day of the month, or transferring money between accounts in such a way that the effective debit is a different month than the credit!)

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#16
post #7

As a college student who often pays for or pays others through Venmo for various expenses, the splitting/combining transactions seems super useful for not losing that information. Will definitely try it out!

Thank you so much! I do believe it definitely reflects modern spending habits :) If you have any questions or issues, feel free to reach out!

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#17

It looks pretty, but unfortunately I found budgeting methods that are not envelope based (such as YNAB where every dollar is assigned a job) are not adequate. After adopting the YNAB method I have seen how far superior it is. If I could combine YNAB's budgeting method with your reporting & analysis we'd have a true winner.

Thanks for the feedback! It is definitely a different way of budgeting. My target audience is more first-time budgeters. I know it would be an uphill battle to convert YNAB'ers since they are loyal to envelope-based method.

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#18
Looks interesting, but like most financial services only helps with my American accounts, and provides only manual entries to help me track my accounts in the EU. The multi-currency aspect would be nice though once Plaid expands more in Europe.

Re: Show HN: Lunch Money, a personal budgeting tool with multi-currency support

#19

Looks interesting, but like most financial services only helps with my American accounts, and provides only manual entries to help me track my accounts in the EU. The multi-currency aspect would be nice though once Plaid expands more in Europe.

Thanks for the feedback! It is a bummer that Plaid is only offered in CA/US right now. I'll be working on allowing importing of bank transactions via CSV soon so hopefully that takes out a bit of the manual work.
Post reply on HN