Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 103 posts

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#71
post #21

Razor Blade 15 works very well, also under heat. The Surface Pro is also fantastic except the lack of webcam support.

What is the Linux story on a surface? I admit I like Microsoft’s products form factor a lot, especially the surface book.

It works - there is a script for Ubuntu that can be found on github that basically takes care of everything. The only issue I have found is that the webcam doesn’t work.

I also haven’t been able to get the 4g to work yet (I have a surface 5).

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#73
post #9
post #5

I also moved off a MacBook to dell XPS but will probably not buy dell again. Customer service was shockingly bad compared to what you get from Apple. I mean really bad (bought in Switzerland). I was looking today at the HUAWEI Matebook X Pro but not thrilled about taking a laptop with nvidia.

Is there still coil whine when running Linux on the XPS?

It's a hit and miss and some editions don't have it at all.

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#74

The Dell XPS 13 Developer Edition is the usual recommendation as far as having the most "Macbook"-like design (e.g. slim, unibody aluminum, but powerful).* ThinkPads generally have pretty solid Linux support, and System76 makes a line of Linux-only laptops, although both of them will be a good bit chunkier than your MBP. Neither are bad laptops if you're willing to trade sleekness for a tad more power or durability.…

After being plagued with a sideloaded linux on XPS15 which produced enough exhaust to keep me warm in winter, I bought a XPS13 last year and have never been happier!

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#75

My xps15 9560 has been a basketcase under ubuntu or arch linux, mostly due to the nvidia gpu never playing well with, well any other gpu. In general I'd recommend avoiding anything with a "hybrid" gpu solution. The downside is you're stuck with a crappy intel gpu, which at high-res (4k) on my xps15 is pretty crap, so I wouldn't get anything beyond a 1080p display with it. I think life would be much better if we could…

never buy an nvidia gpu for linux unless it's for non-graphical computing.

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#76
I would definitely recommend the XPS13. I have the 2018 with the nosecam but other than that it's served me well for the short time I've spent with it.

The newer version does away with the nosecam which is the biggest improvement in my opinion. I'm ambivalent on the fingerprint scanner, but is a welcome addition. Other than these, the line has had only incremental improvements (which is great considering it leaves little to be desired)

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#77
I transitioned from MBP 15" 16GB / 1TB SSD in Nov, as I found MACOSX too restrictive and dissimilar to Linux for my dev purposes. MBP was 5 years old and new MBP only allowed max 32GB RAM with concerns about butterfly keyboard issues. I use my laptop 7 x 14 on dev and it travels with me everywhere so no time to return for something that should not be an issue at time of purchase.

I purchased Lenovo P72 8GB / 256GB SSD 17" with 3 year warranty extension, like AppleCare, and have upped the RAM to 64GB (it is 128GB capable when the RAM becomes more affordable), added 1TB Samsung SSD and an internal 7mm 2TB drive. If SSDs fail, tends to be binary while a drive tends to fail over time (by sector / track) which the drive manages, so better for online backup.

Have installed VMware workstation 15 allowing a win / Linux dev environment and multiple Linux flavor installs. Since I still have two other macs, I have installed MACOSX on a VMware VM as well, using my existing appleID. Runs like a dream and can develop without being online.

I also install various flavors of windows to resolve subscriber issues where it relates to their OS.

If you buy the same machine and need to upgrade RAM under the keyboard, ignore the need for a keyboard removal tool. A youtube video allowed me to achieve that using two credit cards.

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#78
post #29

I am interested in switching from Macbook to Linux laptop. My biggest concern is the different keyboard shortcuts and layouts (most important ones are cmd vs ctrl for shortcuts, but keeping ctrl+C for terminating processes). I bought a cheap Lenovo x230 recently, and the most annoying thing is finding an easy to configure the keyboard shortcuts to be the same as the OSX. Does anyone know if there are any OSes or soft…

They’re not so bad with a bit of practice. In the terminal Ctrl-c is still terminate (SIGINT) so to copy something use Ctrl-Shift-c

Same for paste and cut, use Ctrl-Shift-v or Ctrl-Shift-x.

What I like is that Gnome now provides me with shortcuts for moving windows about that macOS doesn’t. Eg half full screen on the left windowkey-left.

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#79
TLDR: If you don't care about USB-C charging I'd suggest a Librem. Otherwise, I'd go with the new X1 Carbon.

I initially switched from an MBP to an XPS13. Pretty good, but I wasn't super super happy with it, nothing wrong in particular, but it felt a bit plastic-y. Then bought a Lenovo X1C6 as soon as it was announced last year and I'm very happy with it: super solid and no issues with any component.

I also bought a Librem 13 because I wanted a free laptop and because why I love the X1C6 as a machine, I'm not willing to trust Lenovo 100% as far as ethics go. The Librem is a beautiful machine and works really well, however I'm not willing to use it as my main driver because it doesn't have USB-C charging. As soon as they'll release a model with USB-C charging, I'll get it and switch to it.

Re: Ask HN: Best Linux Laptop Replacing a Macbook Pro?

#80
post #29

I am interested in switching from Macbook to Linux laptop. My biggest concern is the different keyboard shortcuts and layouts (most important ones are cmd vs ctrl for shortcuts, but keeping ctrl+C for terminating processes). I bought a cheap Lenovo x230 recently, and the most annoying thing is finding an easy to configure the keyboard shortcuts to be the same as the OSX. Does anyone know if there are any OSes or soft…

Honestly, if this is your big problem with Linux I think you should stay with osx. (of course you can configure shortcuts and there are distros that mimic isx shortcuts)

I'm curious, which distros mimic the OSX shortcuts?
Post reply on HN