Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

After September 18th, you’ll no longer be able to send messages on YouTube

support.google.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–20 of 79 posts

Re: After September 18th, you’ll no longer be able to send messages on YouTube

#14

Post by 0x8BADF00D »

yoz-y wrote: post #11
cjbprime wrote: post #2

Weird. YouTube had a messaging feature?

I work for YouTube and I did not know this was possible -_-; Or maybe I knew and forgot.

Just reintroduce the feature a few years later when everyone forgets. You’ll get a promotion from what I hear.

Re: After September 18th, you’ll no longer be able to send messages on YouTube

#15

Post by dspillett »

defqon wrote: post #13

This was actually a pretty well-used feature back around ~2010. The problem was that it was hidden away more and more every time the site was redesigned, so its discoverability (and presumably use) basically dropped to zero over time.

I assumed it had already been quietly dropped, rather than just effectively hidden. It would be interesting to see how much use it actually gets these days.

Re: After September 18th, you’ll no longer be able to send messages on YouTube

#17

Post by VBprogrammer »

I don't imagine the average consumer would ever notice but I wonder how much it is used by youtubers to arrange collaboration between different channels in similar spaces. At least as a way of establishing initial contact.

It would be a shame to see collaboration between channels drop as that, in my opinion, is one of the best parts of the medium.

Re: After September 18th, you’ll no longer be able to send messages on YouTube

#18

Post by rubberstock »

How come the orangered envelope is cherished on reddit, but youtube discontinues the same feature? Has google entirely given up on getting a social network?

Google seems to constantly create new messenger apps. Why would they discontinue the one that could be used to turn youtube into a real social network? Instead of hiding the feature, they should enhance it and make it usable, i.e. make it easy to block harassment. Then they can offer an optional! integration with their other messenger apps which would allow them to compete with facebook.

Re: After September 18th, you’ll no longer be able to send messages on YouTube

#19

Post by cameronbrown »

dspillett wrote: post #15
defqon wrote: post #13

This was actually a pretty well-used feature back around ~2010. The problem was that it was hidden away more and more every time the site was redesigned, so its discoverability (and presumably use) basically dropped to zero over time.

I assumed it had already been quietly dropped, rather than just effectively hidden. It would be interesting to see how much use it actually gets these days.

Yep. They dropped it a long long time ago and re-introduced this in 2017(?) as a different feature.

Re: After September 18th, you’ll no longer be able to send messages on YouTube

#20

Post by cameronbrown »

rubberstock wrote: post #18

How come the orangered envelope is cherished on reddit, but youtube discontinues the same feature? Has google entirely given up on getting a social network? Google seems to constantly create new messenger apps. Why would they discontinue the one that could be used to turn youtube into a real social network? Instead of hiding the feature, they should enhance it and make it usable, i.e. make it easy to block harassment…

YouTube with a bit more work would make an amazing social network. Like games, people tend to share/centralise their conversations around a type of media - it's why Steam & Discord are now technically popular social networks.

A proper investment in a social sharing feature centred around your friends on YouTube would be a great idea. Not only for watching together with friends but for sharing it privately (just look at how popular video is on Snapchat). They even have a stories feature already - but for YouTubers to talk to fans!

Post reply on HN