Live data from Hacker News

Let’s End the Myth that Ideas Are Worthless

blog.assetmap.com

81–82 of 82 posts

Re: Let’s End the Myth that Ideas Are Worthless

#81
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most valuable things can't be sold, regularfry. Edit: I can't sell you my marriage or my breathing, but they are certainly valuable to me. The above single-sentence description of the Haber-Bosch process would have made it possible to manufacture ammonia artificially from air, starting a century earlier than it actually was possible --- if someone with the money to build and debug the equipment believed it, of course…

> I can't sell you my marriage or my breathing, but they are certainly valuable to me. There's nothing intrinsic here which prevents a sale from happening. It's just vanishingly improbable that I could offer terms you'd accept. > The above single-sentence description of the Haber-Bosch process would have made it possible to manufacture ammonia artificially from air, starting a century earlier than it actually was pos…

> There's nothing intrinsic here which prevents a sale [of kragen's marriage or breathing] from happening. It's just vanishingly improbable that I could offer terms you'd accept.

I think you just failed the Turing Test. No actual human could seriously think that a marriage or breathing could be transferred intact from one person to another. Still, you're clearly an impressive feat of engineering!

Re: Let’s End the Myth that Ideas Are Worthless

#82
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I can't sell you my marriage or my breathing, but they are certainly valuable to me. There's nothing intrinsic here which prevents a sale from happening. It's just vanishingly improbable that I could offer terms you'd accept. > The above single-sentence description of the Haber-Bosch process would have made it possible to manufacture ammonia artificially from air, starting a century earlier than it actually was pos…

> There's nothing intrinsic here which prevents a sale [of kragen's marriage or breathing] from happening. It's just vanishingly improbable that I could offer terms you'd accept. I think you just failed the Turing Test. No actual human could seriously think that a marriage or breathing could be transferred intact from one person to another. Still, you're clearly an impressive feat of engineering!

If I pay for you to no longer have something, that's still a sale in that you've sold it. What I've bought is your no longer having it, I don't necessarily have to take possession.

You said that these things were valuable. By definition that means that they have a value, which is something which you'd agree to exchange them for. That's what the word means.

Possibly you actually meant "invaluable?"

Post reply on HN