Live data from Hacker News

Nipkow disk

en.wikipedia.org

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: Nipkow disk

#11
The spelling of disk, with a K, intrigues me, since I was under the impression that disk-with-a-K was short for "diskette", meaning a circular spinning object protected inside an outer casing.

Circular flat objects are spelled disc, with a C.

Hence floppy disk, hard disk, but compact disc.

(MiniDisc is the only exception to this rule that I can think of, probably because it is a trade mark.)

Re: Nipkow disk

#12

The spelling of disk, with a K, intrigues me, since I was under the impression that disk-with-a-K was short for "diskette", meaning a circular spinning object protected inside an outer casing. Circular flat objects are spelled disc, with a C. Hence floppy disk, hard disk, but compact disc. (MiniDisc is the only exception to this rule that I can think of, probably because it is a trade mark.)

Seems Wikipedia has a dedicated article on the subject!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spelling_of_disc

Re: Nipkow disk

#14
post #5

William Osman tried to build a mechanical display around these: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R96TtG5FCTU

He seems to really be overcomplicating its construction with all those fancy 21st century electronics when in reality you can build it with early 20th century materials. I wonder if a camera obscura would be enough to create the focused image instead of having to bother with lenses.

Probably, but that would require even more light.

Re: Nipkow disk

#15
post #6

Here is an excellent in-depth explanation of the concept from one of my favorite educational YouTube channels - Technology Connections: https://youtu.be/v5OANXk-6-w

I just watched that and have to agree, an excellent in-depth explanation it was indeed, with a lovely demonstration.

Re: Nipkow disk

#16
post #12

The spelling of disk, with a K, intrigues me, since I was under the impression that disk-with-a-K was short for "diskette", meaning a circular spinning object protected inside an outer casing. Circular flat objects are spelled disc, with a C. Hence floppy disk, hard disk, but compact disc. (MiniDisc is the only exception to this rule that I can think of, probably because it is a trade mark.)

Seems Wikipedia has a dedicated article on the subject! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spelling_of_disc

Relevant bit:

> in the case of flat, rotational data storage media the convention is that the spelling disk is used for magnetic storage (e.g. hard disks) while disc is used for optical storage (e.g. compact discs, better known as CDs). When there is no clear convention, the spelling disk is more popular in American English, while the spelling disc is more popular in British English.

Re: Nipkow disk

#18
post #2

I don't understand why you have to approximate straight scanlines by using a fraction of a really large disk. What's the disadvantage in using a smaller disk and letting the scanlines be curved?

I would use a drum instead. You can make the scanlines near-perfectly linear if you look from a right angle.

Re: Nipkow disk

#19
post #12

The spelling of disk, with a K, intrigues me, since I was under the impression that disk-with-a-K was short for "diskette", meaning a circular spinning object protected inside an outer casing. Circular flat objects are spelled disc, with a C. Hence floppy disk, hard disk, but compact disc. (MiniDisc is the only exception to this rule that I can think of, probably because it is a trade mark.)

Seems Wikipedia has a dedicated article on the subject! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spelling_of_disc

I should have known, Wikipedia knows everything.

I didn't know that disk = diskette was a British thing! And I am British. So I guess that makes sense.

Post reply on HN