Live data from Hacker News

Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

jacek.zlydach.pl

11–20 of 657 posts

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#11
post #4

Maybe some of it...but without any advertising at all it would be really hard to know what products or out there or even that there is a restaurant on the other end of the block.

reducing consumption would be a benefit if you think about it from a climate change angle... For restaurants, I usually search for them in a directory and not in ads...

How do you think that directory makes the money necessary to produce and maintain it? Generally, ads.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#12

Maybe some of it...but without any advertising at all it would be really hard to know what products or out there or even that there is a restaurant on the other end of the block.

> without any advertising at all it would be really hard to know what products or out there or even that there is a restaurant on the other end of the block

There's a huge difference between reviews, directories, and advertising. You can seek out information without being pushed advertisements. Another facet: whether payment from the entity being promoted is involved and affects placement.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#13
post #4

Maybe some of it...but without any advertising at all it would be really hard to know what products or out there or even that there is a restaurant on the other end of the block.

reducing consumption would be a benefit if you think about it from a climate change angle... For restaurants, I usually search for them in a directory and not in ads...

In NYC, there are many pop up events including food events, which wouldn’t show up in a food directory site, but they do show up on Instagram ads.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#14

We get rid of it, Google/Facebook/etc. shut down. While social media is of arguable benefits, Google has provided incalculable value to the world. Ads are the magic money fountain that give them the power to organize all of human knowledge, a phenomenal resource anyone can tap.

I'm not convinced that there's no other possible business model for a search engine.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#15

Maybe some of it...but without any advertising at all it would be really hard to know what products or out there or even that there is a restaurant on the other end of the block.

A good portion of advertising is probably a net negative to society in the form of promoting consumption beyond healthy/financially responsible levels. However, anyone who's ever started a product business knows that advertising is often the only effective way to get new customers, even if your product is amazingly helpful to people. It's difficult to draw the line between advertising that is helpful and advertising that is harmful.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#17

We get rid of it, Google/Facebook/etc. shut down. While social media is of arguable benefits, Google has provided incalculable value to the world. Ads are the magic money fountain that give them the power to organize all of human knowledge, a phenomenal resource anyone can tap.

That sounds fairly alarmist. I'm sure there's a (small) subset of users who'd be willing to pay for services like those if there weren't any creepy advertising tricks happening in the background. Would the business model change? Certainly. But shut down? Probably not.

Google/Facebook are big and motivated enough that they could probably figure out how to make money.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#18
post #7

Targeted Instagram ads have been very useful to me recently. I just moved apartments, and the ads have been showcasing products that I wouldn’t have otherwise known about. The argument can be made that maybe I didn’t need these things in the first place. But I want them, it makes me happy, and these ads have saved me time.

This is a pretty rare ad experienced. They're much more commonly used to generate desire that doesn't need to exist; to manipulate public opinion in a harmful way; to sell dangerous products; to astroturf; etc.

The fact that people attempt to ignore most ads, with varying degrees of success, tells you that they're net-harmful.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#19

"Businesses are made of people, and people have ethics. If you're running one, consider the way you advertise. Are you aiming at making mutually beneficial transactions, or are you just trying to milk you users out of their hard-earned cash? Not all advertising is inherently harmful to individuals or society. " So, some kinds of cancers are OK. It's hard to take this sort of article too seriously when it undermines i…

I think you're reading "is" in a particular (and reasonable) way, but there are other ways of reading it. For example "is" can mean "is essentially" or fundamentally, or it could mean "is currently".

The fact that advertising doesn't have to be a cancer is compatible with the claim that it is one at this point in history.

Re: Advertising Is a Cancer on Society

#20

This is a dogmatic viewpoint I think often seen in very technical people who are unwilling to see the interconnectedness of how our society works. I bet there's any number of things this person values that simply wouldn't exist without advertising. It's a childish and immature opinion really. Anyone who hates advertising this much should show their commitment by working at an organization that does not advertise. Loa…

What valuable things wouldn't exist without advertising?
Post reply on HN