Live data from Hacker News

US could ban 'addictive' autoplay videos and infinite scrolling online

theguardian.com

1–10 of 68 posts

Re: US could ban 'addictive' autoplay videos and infinite scrolling online

#4
Regulating infinite scrolling seems like a major overregulation. Even if it kinda makes sense in terms of FB, Twitter, and other social media newsfeeds, it's still a great (and beneficial) UX in many other cases.

Overusing social media could be solved via e.g. Screen Time or a similar time-limiting solution (perhaps w/o an option to "snooze" the daily limit if a parent set it on a child's device).

Re: US could ban 'addictive' autoplay videos and infinite scrolling online

#8
I don't like sites with autoplay. I only expect autoplay when the page I am about to visit is in a video site like YouTube. I hate it when I am reading a news article and a video autoplays.

Autoscrolling also can be irritating. If I click a TechCrunch article on HN, I don't want TC to load more articles at the end of the article I was reading without my consent. It is better to suggest related articles and give me an option to click on them if I am interested.

Re: US could ban 'addictive' autoplay videos and infinite scrolling online

#9
I mean, sure, I agree on the motives. But there are the usual questions about tech regulation:

1. How hard will it be enforced? Turns out GDPR, for example, has been significantly harder to enforce than the EU expected.

2. How punitive is the punishment? Does this become just one more "cost of doing business" that further raises the barrier to entry to competition to the tech giants?

Post reply on HN