Live data from Hacker News

GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

github.com

31–40 of 111 posts

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#31
post #25
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Negotiating with a non-US entity for as smooth a mirror as possible? Not sure, but resistance to stupidity isn't futile.

While I’ve no familiarity with the law in this area, I’d imagine this is surely still illegal too? If one could just openly pass the business to a foreign partner it would somewhat defeat the purpose of sanctions.

I don't want to be the one to invoke Godwin's law, but there are ways to remain within the law and still resist in a meaningful way when the stakes are high.

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#33
post #31
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I’ve no familiarity with the law in this area, I’d imagine this is surely still illegal too? If one could just openly pass the business to a foreign partner it would somewhat defeat the purpose of sanctions.

I don't want to be the one to invoke Godwin's law, but there are ways to remain within the law and still resist in a meaningful way when the stakes are high.

> when the stakes are high.

The stakes are not high here.

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#34
post #25
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Negotiating with a non-US entity for as smooth a mirror as possible? Not sure, but resistance to stupidity isn't futile.

While I’ve no familiarity with the law in this area, I’d imagine this is surely still illegal too? If one could just openly pass the business to a foreign partner it would somewhat defeat the purpose of sanctions.

Yeah, watching Hacker News try to violate sanctions from first principles is amusing.

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#35
post #33
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't want to be the one to invoke Godwin's law, but there are ways to remain within the law and still resist in a meaningful way when the stakes are high.

> when the stakes are high. The stakes are not high here.

That comment deserves more detail. Blocking an entire sovereign nation from significant useful "free" information seems pretty important to me.

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#36
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it's the right thing to do and MS has the power to do it.

no they dont

Does the US law say that the repos should be revoked with no notice, or that a zip of the code can not be sent when revoking access?

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#37
The US is not going to lift these restrictions. Why would they? If you live in these terrible places, I’m sorry, but you need to start fighting at home. I don’t know enough about your specific situations or what level of action you should take, but everything from peaceful protest to armed rebellion are options. Yes, you might have to die. You might be killed just for peaceful protest or if you’re government suspects you might be “trouble.” This is your burden, but liberty is worth it.

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#38
post #35
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> when the stakes are high. The stakes are not high here.

That comment deserves more detail. Blocking an entire sovereign nation from significant useful "free" information seems pretty important to me.

Iranian users being unable to use GitHub is an incredibly insignificant issue.

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#39
post #6
post #4

This is incredibly dumb. Hopefully some GitHub exec intervenes. Edit: Happy to take the karma hit. Stupid is stupid, regardless of jurisdiction and consequences.

Why would an exec intentionally violate US law for this?

There is no US law that forces Microsoft-hub to do what they did. They can easily fight whatever order they received if they wanted to.

Re: GitHub banned all Iranian users. Our accounts are restricted. Please support us

#40
Russia invades and takes over Crimea (again). This has repercussions for the people living there, many of whom are displacing those who lived there before.

Iran threatens to nuke other countries as soon as they can develop the nukes. They are in the process of trying to take over the whole middle ease, fighting in Yemen, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, etc. This has repercussions for the people living there.

Post reply on HN