Live data from Hacker News

National Self-Sufficiency (1933)

mtholyoke.edu

1–6 of 6 posts

Re: National Self-Sufficiency (1933)

#4

The lowest common denominator in all of this, then and today, are the people we vote into office. Local elections about 20% turnout. Presidential about 50%? The movie Idiocracy doesn't seem like satire anymore.

Worth pointing out that some places like Australia have mandatory voting and they still manage to elect some really terrible, racist politicians

Re: National Self-Sufficiency (1933)

#5

The lowest common denominator in all of this, then and today, are the people we vote into office. Local elections about 20% turnout. Presidential about 50%? The movie Idiocracy doesn't seem like satire anymore.

We should be so lucky to get an Idiocracy outcome in this country.[1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmZOZjHjT5E

Re: National Self-Sufficiency (1933)

#6
Everyone but the most callous of businessthralls has felt, at times, the same reaction as Keynes elicits here, against the ugliness of a world turned by free trade and markets. Such arrangements of human desire (what else is a market?) do occasionally produce greatness and the sublime, but only with the mediation of a culture prior-to and underdetermined-by themselves, and amounting to nothing compared with the feelings of greatness and sublime that nation-states have proven capable of achieving: for example, the most ineconomic Apollo 11.