Live data from Hacker News

Honeybees are found to interact with Quantum fields

neuroquantology.com

31–32 of 32 posts

Re: Honeybees are found to interact with Quantum fields

#31

I'll repost my comment from the last version of this article, since I don't think any new developments have invalidated it. This connection to QFT is almost surely nonsense. The flag manifold in question comes from matrix groups; basically, consider some subset of 3x3 matrices which satisfy a certain property. I.e., certain types of transformations of a 3d space. While the space of 3x3 matrices has 3x3=9 dimensions,…

And from someone who studies neurobiology and animal behavior with a specialty in social insects...

This is bullshit. The dance is a solved problem. There are plenty of mysteries about honey bees, and this isn't one of them. A few summers ago I worked with a guy that could read the dance so well that we could physically locate the place the bee was dancing to. (We were studying quorum sensing behavior, which isn't a solved problem; how do bees collaborate to decide which new location to move to?)

Re: Honeybees are found to interact with Quantum fields

#32

I'll repost my comment from the last version of this article, since I don't think any new developments have invalidated it. This connection to QFT is almost surely nonsense. The flag manifold in question comes from matrix groups; basically, consider some subset of 3x3 matrices which satisfy a certain property. I.e., certain types of transformations of a 3d space. While the space of 3x3 matrices has 3x3=9 dimensions,…

Are you a biologist? > Inside the bee's head is an ODE (ordinary differential equation) solver > basically an analog computer. Just think of the ODE solver as a complicated > timer, but with output depending on both time and some hidden variable. > These are common objects in biology, and don't require many neurons. Do you have any sources to back any of this up at all? EDIT: Here's a very long list of papers on Hone…

I AM a biologist, and a specialist on social insects, and sure, it's not understood perfectly. But this guy's statement is valid.
Post reply on HN